Book of Abstracts
From the North Sea Lowlands to the Celtic Edge
Celebrating Fifty Years of Mapping in the Dutch North Sea
Sponsored by:
Organized by:
Preface
Welcome to Utrecht!
Fifty years ago, in 1969, Erno Oele and Cees Laban finalized a Quaternary geological map depicting the
northern half of the Dutch North Sea. By combining seismic data and descriptions of about eighty
vibrocores with analyses of palynomorphs, they were able to capture half a million years of geological
history, from the Elsterian glaciation to the present.
We have come a long way since then. Quaternary geological maps of the North Sea, English Channel
and Celtic Sea summarize decades of intense marine surveying, laboratory work and drawing, and
provide the context for research on topics ranging from ice-sheet configuration in the North Sea basin
to terrigenous fluxes at the Celtic Margin. We have been able to answer some fundamental questions
about the impact of growing and shrinking ice sheets on continental-scale drainage systems, the role
of climate change in triggering extreme events, the defining influence of paleolandscapes on human
migration and well-being, and commonalities between continental sedimentary and marine isotope
records. Still, many challenges remain and important follow-up questions have arisen that can only be
answered with new information and knowledge.
Various interdisciplinary groups are currently intensifying their research on the shallow subsurface of
the North Sea, English Channel and southern Celtic Sea, triggered in part by the availability of new
seismic surveys and boreholes made to support large-scale offshore windfarm development. Aligning
this work and planning joint expeditions is crucial to unravel a unique record of glacial and interglacial
sediments and landforms on a scale covering entire drainage systems, marine basins, and past
landscapes home to Paleolithic, Mesolithic and Neolithic Man. It will help identify causes and effects
of rapid environmental change, and shed light on the way early humans used the available natural
resources.
We invited Phil Gibbard, Natasha Barlow, Luc Amkreutz, Vera Van Lancker and Samuel Toucanne to
anchor a program around glacial and interglacial records, climate and environmental reconstructions,
drowned landscapes, seabed mapping and subsurface modeling, and equipment and methodology.
We want to facilitate networking through an interactive program that includes keynotes, oral
presentations, a poster session, and informal as well as plenary discussion sessions. To help you
explore the city, a walking dinner will be served in one of Utrecht’s quayside restaurants along the
main canal. We hope that our conference will be the start of a long-term and fruitful cooperation!
We thank TNO – Geological Survey of the Netherlands, Flanders Marine Institute, the Dutch Research
Council and the Cultural Heritage Agency of the Netherlands for sponsoring our conference, and the
European Marine Board for providing copies of the position paper on Land Beneath the Waves. We
wish you all an inspiring and enjoyable event!
The organizing committee,
Sytze van Heteren, Ina Vissinga-Schalkwijk, Tine Missiaen, Marc De Batist, Vince Gaffney and Gert-Jan
Reichart
Conference locations
Important locations for this conference are shown on the maps below.
The plenary sessions with oral presentations and posters are at Media Plaza, Croeselaan 6 in Utrecht
(yellow arrow), which is very close to Utrecht Central Station (red arrow).
On Tuesday night, the conference dinner will be hosted by Humphrey's Utrecht, Stadhuisbrug 3 in
Utrecht. It is in the city center, about 2 km from Media Plaza.
Organization North Sea to Celtic Edge
Contact:
•
•
info@northseatocelticedge.org
https://northseatocelticedge.org
Organizing Committee:
•
•
•
•
•
•
dr. Sytze van Heteren (TNO – Geological Survey of the Netherlands, chair)
Ina Vissinga-Schalkwijk (TNO – Geological Survey of the Netherlands, logistics)
dr. Tine Missiaen (Flanders Marine Institute)
prof. dr. Marc De Batist (Renard Centre for Marine Geology, Ghent University)
prof. dr. Vincent Gaffney (University of Bradford)
prof. dr. Gert-Jan Reichart (Royal Netherlands Institute for Sea Research and Faculty of
Geosciences, Utrecht University)
Scientific Committee:
•
•
•
•
dr. Freek Busschers (TNO – Geological Survey of the Netherlands, chair)
dr. Fabien Paquet (Bureau de Recherches Géologiques et Minières)
dr. Matthew Owen (Geological Survey of Denmark and Greenland)
Garry Momber MSc. (Maritime Archaeology Trust)
Final program
November 18
12:00 Registration and lunch
13:00 Sytze van Heteren - Opening remarks and word of welcome to our special guest Cees Laban
13:05: Michiel van der Meulen - Fifty years of geological mapping in the Dutch North Sea
13:15 Phil Gibbard - The Quaternary evolution of the North Sea
13:45 Session 1 (Subsurface records; chair - Carol Cotterill)
Dag Ottesen - The Quaternary North Sea Basin. Infill history and sedimentary
processes (O)
Stephen Eaton - Palaeogeographic change in response to glacial/interglacial cycles:
Middle and Upper Pleistocene stratigraphy of the southern North Sea (O)
Matthew Owen - Late Quaternary geological processes from the southeast Skagerrak
– a transnational geological feature (O)
Frank Wesselingh - On the origin of Late Quaternary arctic marine faunas:
implications for landscape evolution in the southern North Sea Basin during the Late
Pleistocene (O)
Maikel De Clercq - The evolution of the Last Interglacial North Sea reconstructed
using preserved wave- and tide-dominated paleo-estuarine infills on the Belgian
Continental Shelf (O)
14:55 Coffee break and posters
15:20 Session 1 (Large-scale drainage; chair - Matthew Owen)
Fabien Paquet - One network may hide others – toward a comprehensive scenario
for Neogene superimposed valley networks along the English Channel (O)
Sanjeev Gupta - Opening of the Dover Strait: Constraints on landscape evolution
from high resolution sonars and sub-bottom data (O)
David Garcia Moreno - Evolution of southern North Sea drainage systems during
Middle-Late Pleistocene marine lowstands (O)
Jörg Lang - The impact of Middle Pleistocene glacial lake-outburst floods on the
meltwater-drainage system of northern central Europe (P1 - pitch by Jutta
Winsemann)
Alain Trentesaux - Fosse drilling needed (P2)
Bart Meijninger - Anomalous buried scour hollows in the Dutch Borssele wind-farm
site (P3)
Maikel De Clercq - Glacial erratics on the Belgian Continental Shelf: analysis, origin
and transportation mechanisms (P4)
16:25 Short break
16:35 Session 1 (Ice-marginal landforms and processes; chair - Katrine Andresen)
Margaret Stewart - The tunnel valleys of the central and northern North Sea (56°N –
62°N): distribution, characteristics and generations (O)
Arne Lohrberg - Paleolandscapes and ice-marginal subsurface landforms in the
German sector of the southeastern North Sea imaged by closely spaced highresolution 2D multi-channel reflection seismics (O)
Kirstin Johnson - Deposition of proglacial sediments along an active ice margin during
the Last Glacial Maximum, Dogger Bank, southern central North Sea (O)
Mattijs Vollenberg - The effect of boundary conditions on morphometric parameters
of tunnel valleys in the North Sea (P5)
Louise Callard - The last glacial cycle in the North Sea Basin: research highlights from
the BRITICE-CHRONO project (P6)
17:30 Poster event (introduced and sponsored by the Cultural Heritage Agency of the Netherlands)
with snacks and drinks, information stands, break-out session to discuss white paper
19:00 End of program
November 19
08:45 Session 1 (Ice-marginal tectonics and dynamics; chair - Louise Callard)
Jutta Winsemann - Seismic interpretation and structural restoration of the
Heligoland glaciotectonic thrust-fault complex: deformation during a pre-Elsterian
ice advance into the southern North Sea Basin? (O)
Volkhard Spiess - Glacial deformation in the eastern German North Sea – from
shallow fracturing to large-scale thrusting (O)
David Roberts - Ice marginal dynamics of the last British-Irish Ice Sheet in the
southern North Sea: ice limits, timing and the influence of the Dogger Bank (O)
Emrys Phillips - Glacitectonic evidence of ice lobe interaction across Dogger Bank
(southern central North Sea) during the Last Glacial Maximum (O)
09:45 Short break
09:55 Session 1 (Celtic Sea; chair - Louise Callard)
Katrien Van Landeghem - The role of the Irish Sea Ice Stream in the palaeo-landscape
evolution of the Irish Sea, Celtic Sea and the shelf edge (O)
Zsuzsanna Tóth - Geomorphological and seismostratigraphic evidence for
multidirectional polyphase glaciation of the northern Celtic Sea (P7)
10:15 Natasha Barlow - The North Sea: a climatic and environmental archive
10:45 Coffee break and posters
11:10 Session 2 (Climate, sea level and vegetation; chair - Simon Fitch)
Timme Donders - Land–sea coupling of early Pleistocene glacial cycles in the
southern North Sea (O)
Freek Busschers - Peat Hunt: the 2017 and 2018 RV Pelagia early Holocene sea-level
cruises on the North Sea (O)
Marc Hijma - SLIP Hunt: first paleo sea-level data from the 2017 and 2018 RV Pelagia
Early Holocene sea-level cruises (O)
Lutz Reinhardt - Relative sea-level change in northwest Europe and the southern
North Sea during the Holocene: Determination of isostatic and (neo)tectonic
subsidence in the German Bight (P8)
Zicarlo van Aalderen - Post-glacial vegetation history of the Dogger Bank, North Sea
using plant macrofossil analysis (P9)
Wim Hoek - Towards integrated drowned landscape reconstructions of the North Sea
(P10)
Daniel Hepp - The Elbe Paleovalley and its tributaries: Late glacial to postglacial
drainage system of the paleolandscape in today’s German Bight (North Sea) (P11)
12:15 Lunch and posters
13:15 Session 2 (Neotectonics and isostasy; chair - Vanessa Heyvaert)
Sarah Louise Bradley - Glacial isostatic adjustment and sea level of north-west
Europe (O)
Ronald van Balen - Late Glacial surface rupturing earthquakes in the Roer Valley Rift
System (O)
13:45 Session 2 (Eemian and Weichselian Early Glacial; chair - Vanessa Heyvaert)
Kay Beets - New age and climate data from the Eemian sedimentary record in the
Amsterdam Saalian glacial basin (O)
Jeroen Schokker - Reconstructing Eemian to Early Weichselian coastal and shallowmarine environments in the Amersfoort glacial basin at the southern North Sea edge
(O)
Victor Cartelle - Tracing the Eemian: coastal response to Last Interglacial sea-level
rise in the southern North Sea (O)
14:30 Coffee break and posters
14:55 Luc Amkreutz - Doggerland emerging: a survey of the archaeological potential of a vast
prehistoric landscape
15:25 Session 3 (Paleolandscape reconstructions; chair - Alain Trentesaux)
Carol Cotterill - Buried landscapes and the issue of seismic scale: A case study from
Dogger Bank, southern North Sea (O)
Samuel Griffiths - The significance of inferred Quaternary coastal and intertidal
landscapes (O)
Rachel Bynoe - Targeting submerged Pleistocene landscapes off Happisburgh, UK (O)
Rachel Harding - Revealing the lost landscapes of Cardigan Bay, Wales: mapping the
Holocene transgression using parametric echosounder data (O)
Frieda Bogemans - High Tide – Low Tide. Bruges’ late-medieval harbor system as a
maritime cultural landscape - an interdisciplinary research project (P13)
16:30 Short break
16:40 Session 3 (Context for artefacts and fossils; chair - Renée de Bruijn)
Hans Vandendriessche - Out of Doggerland? Early Holocene climate change and the
Mesolithic ‘Rhine-Meuse-Scheldt culture’ (O)
Kim Cohen - Last Glacial river valleys of the Southern North Sea Basin: continuouscover context for spotty-cover finds and sites (O)
Bjørn Smit - 'Peopling Doggerland' submerged stone age finds from the Dutch North
Sea (P14)
Tine Missiaen - The Scheur – a unique prehistoric fossil graveyard off the Belgian
coast (P15)
Bram Langeveld - Using citizen science to study fossil vertebrates from the North Sea
(P30)
17:25 Session 3 (Advice and research agenda; chair - Renée de Bruijn)
Hans Peeters - The North Sea Prehistory Research and Management Agenda 2019
(O)
Katrine Juul Andresen - The geo-archaeological potential of the eastern North Sea –
initial considerations based on existing geophysical data (P16)
17:45 Group photo
17:50 End of day
19:15 Conference dinner
November 20
08:45 Vera Van Lancker - Transnational seabed mapping and subsurface modeling
09:15 Session 4 (New datasets and opportunities; chair - Marc De Batist)
Niels Noergaard-Pedersen - Danish North Sea marine geological data as input for
transnational large-scale projects (O)
Menno Hofstra - High-resolution investigations of the shallow subsurface in the
Dutch Sector of the North Sea for aiding the development of wind farm zones (O)
Lars Kint - Geomorphological mapping of the Belgian seabed and its submerged
landscapes (P17)
Riccardo Arosio - A very high resolution geomorphological and habitat mapping
investigation of the Northern Paleovalley, English Channel (La Manche) (P18)
Sytze van Heteren - Hierarchies in geomorphological seabed mapping for multipurpose end use (P19)
10:00 Short break
10:10 Session 4 (Small- and large-scale mapping; chair - Fabien Paquet)
Peter Vos - Mapping program of the coastal plain of the Netherlands (O)
Simon Fitch - Lost Frontiers: Mapping and prospecting submerged Holocene
landscapes (O)
Maikel De Clercq - Geo-archaeological mapping of the Zeebrugge area, Belgium (P20)
Marcel Bakker - Mapping the southernmost Weichselian ice margin on the Dutch
shelf using multibeam bathymetry, sidescan backscatter and 3D seismics (P21 - pitch
by Sytze van Heteren)
Kay Koster - Coastal plain mapping for archaeological research: a new geological map
of the cities of The Hague and Rijswijk (the Netherlands) (P22)
10:55 Coffee break and posters
11:20 Session 4 (Learning from maps and subsurface models; chair - Lutz Reinhardt)
Jelte Stam - Construction of a transnational offshore sand-resource model for the
southern North Sea area (O)
Harm Jan Pierik - How tides and rivers shape levees and crevasses: Holocene
overbank phases of the Old Rhine river, the Netherlands (O)
Hanno Keil - Classification and mapping of small-scale ‚complex’ Pleistocene
seismoacoustic facies in the Eastern North-Sea (P23)
Harm Jan Pierik - How tidal ingressions along the North Sea grow and heal: impact of
storms (P24)
12:00 Samuel Toucanne - Quaternary paleodrainage In NW Europe: a marine perspective
12:30 Lunch and posters
13:30 Session 5 (DNA, geochemistry and dating; chair - Marc Hijma)
Roselyn Ware - Exploiting sedaDNA to trace the impact of the Storegga slide tsunami
on the Doggerland paleolandscape (O)
Eveline Altena - Resurfacing Doggerland genomes. Whole genome analysis of huntergatherer remains from Doggerland (O)
Tanya Lippmann - The greenhouse gas emission potential of North Sea peat
sediments (O)
Rick Hennekam - Reconstructing environmental change in the North Sea using novel
XRF-core-scanning methods (O)
Jakob Wallinga - North Sea sediments in a new light - possibilities and limitations of
luminescence dating (O)
Vanessa Heyvaert - GEN-EX – Application of metagenomic analyses to extreme wave
deposits in the Shetland Islands, UK (P25)
14:45 Short break
14:55 Session 5 (Seismics and granulometry; chair - Freek Busschers)
Tine Missiaen - New developments in seismic techniques for archaeological
prospection at sea (O)
Seger van den Brenk - Buried channels revealed by magnetic data (O)
Axel Muller - The Marine Prehistoric Sampler, new ways of survey on water (O)
Hans van Hateren - Determination of sediment transport mode based on grain size
and shape data from dynamic image analysis (1): testing a new methodology (O)
Unze van Buuren - Determination of sediment transport mode based on grain size
and shape data from dynamic image analysis (2): application to an active coastal
dune system (P26)
Maarten Prins - Determination of sediment transport mode based on grain size and
shape data from dynamic image analysis (3): application to a secondary tidal inlet
system (P27)
Stefan Carpentier - Recycling vintage geophysical and geological data for cost
optimization of offshore wind farm design (P28)
Jelte Stam - Reconstructing vintage seismic data for geological mapping of the Dutch
North Sea sector (P29)
16:10 Coffee break and posters
16:35 Discussion about the way forward (chair - Sytze van Heteren)
17:15 Michiel van der Meulen - Wrap-up and actions
17:25 Vincent Gaffney - Closing remarks
17:30 End of conference
List of posters
with location as shown on floor plan
Jörg Lang - The impact of Middle Pleistocene glacial lake-outburst floods on the meltwater-drainage
system of northern central Europe (P1)
Alain Trentesaux - Fosse drilling needed (P2)
Bart Meijninger - Anomalous buried scour hollows in the Dutch Borssele wind-farm site (P3)
Maikel De Clercq - Glacial erratics on the Belgian Continental Shelf: analysis, origin and
transportation mechanisms (P4)
Mattijs Vollenberg - The effect of boundary conditions on morphometric parameters of tunnel
valleys in the North Sea (P5)
Louise Callard - The last glacial cycle in the North Sea Basin: research highlights from the BRITICECHRONO project (P6)
Zsuzsanna Tóth - Geomorphological and seismostratigraphic evidence for multidirectional polyphase
glaciation of the northern Celtic Sea (P7)
Lutz Reinhardt - Relative sea-level change in northwest Europe and the southern North Sea during
the Holocene: Determination of isostatic and (neo)tectonic subsidence in the German Bight (P8)
Zicarlo van Aalderen - Post-glacial vegetation history of the Dogger Bank, North Sea using plant
macrofossil analysis (P9)
Wim Hoek - Towards integrated drowned landscape reconstructions of the North Sea (P10)
Daniel Hepp - The Elbe Paleovalley and its tributaries: Late glacial to postglacial drainage system of
the paleolandscape in today’s German Bight (North Sea) (P11)
Lieven Naudts - NewRV: A new multidisciplinary research vessel to replace the RV A962 Belgica (P12)
Frieda Bogemans - High Tide – Low Tide. Bruges’ late-medieval harbor system as a maritime cultural
landscape - an interdisciplinary research project (P13)
Bjørn Smit - 'Peopling Doggerland' submerged stone age finds from the Dutch North Sea (P14)
Tine Missiaen - The Scheur – a unique prehistoric fossil graveyard off the Belgian coast (P15)
Katrine Juul Andresen - The geo-archaeological potential of the eastern North Sea – initial
considerations based on existing geophysical data (P16)
Lars Kint - Geomorphological mapping of the Belgian seabed and its submerged landscapes (P17)
Riccardo Arosio - A very high resolution geomorphological and habitat mapping investigation of the
Northern Paleovalley, English Channel (La Manche) (P18)
Sytze van Heteren - Hierarchies in geomorphological seabed mapping for multi-purpose end use
(P19)
Maikel De Clercq - Geo-archaeological mapping of the Zeebrugge area, Belgium (P20)
Marcel Bakker - Mapping the southernmost Weichselian ice margin on the Dutch shelf using
multibeam bathymetry, sidescan backscatter and 3D seismics (P21)
Kay Koster - Coastal plain mapping for archaeological research: a new geological map of the cities of
The Hague and Rijswijk (the Netherlands) (P22)
Hanno Keil - Classification and mapping of small-scale ‚complex’ Pleistocene seismoacoustic facies in
the Eastern North-Sea (P23)
Harm Jan Pierik - How tidal ingressions along the North Sea grow and heal: impact of storms (P24)
Vanessa Heyvaert - GEN-EX – Application of metagenomic analyses to extreme wave deposits in the
Shetland Islands, UK (P25)
Unze van Buuren - Determination of sediment transport mode based on grain size and shape data
from dynamic image analysis (2): application to an active coastal dune system (P26)
Maarten Prins - Determination of sediment transport mode based on grain size and shape data from
dynamic image analysis (3): application to a secondary tidal inlet system (P27)
Stefan Carpentier - Recycling vintage geophysical and geological data for cost optimization of
offshore wind farm design (P28)
Jelte Stam - Reconstructing vintage seismic data for geological mapping of the Dutch North Sea
sector (P29)
Bram Langeveld - Using citizen science to study fossil vertebrates from the North Sea (P30)
Peter Vos, Renée de Bruijn, Kay Koster - Mapping the Netherlands: the coastal plain (work in
progress) (Map 1)
Peter Vos, Renée de Bruijn, Kay Koster - Mapping the Netherlands: top Pleistocene (2015) (Map 2)
Peter Vos, Renée de Bruijn, Kay Koster - Mapping the Netherlands: top Pleistocene (now) (Map 3)
Abstracts of presentations
in order of the conference program
The Quaternary Evolution of the North Sea
Philip Gibbard
University of Cambridge
The island of Britain is separated from the Continent by the North Sea and the English Channel. This
talk will present some of major events that occurred to shape these seaways. Throughout the last 2-3
million years, the build up and decay of ice sheets on the continents have driven changes of global
sea-level. For much of the Pleistocene, low global sea-levels exposed shallow areas, like the North
Sea. Driven by climatic fluctuations, these sea-level changes resulted in cycles of emergence and
submergence of the sea floor.
Although there were earlier events, the first major extension of a continental-scale ice sheet into
lowland regions occurred about 450 ka (Elsterian /Anglian Stage). Critically, this ice advanced across
the emergent North Sea floor, blocking the northwards-flowing rivers and causing a glacial lake to
develop in the basin south of the ice front. Once dammed, the water that continued flowing from
much of western Europe’s rivers caused the lake level to rise. The substantial land barrier, the Weald–
Artois Anticline, was eventually breached allowing the lake to drain to the ocean via the Channel River
(fleuve Manche). The narrow waterway thus formed became the Dover Strait (Pas de Calais), linking
the North Sea to the English Channel.
The breaching of the ridge to form the Dover Strait was critical to the evolution of the North Sea and
Channel from then on. The drainage of the lake forced the rivers Thames and Scheldt through the
new Dover Strait into the Channel River. The system continued to evolve for the next 200 000 y, but
events climaxed some 160 000 y ago when the major Saalian / Wolstonian continental-scale glaciation
occurred. Recent research demonstrates that in the central Netherlands the Rhine and Meuse (Maas)
were forced to flow SW into a second ice-marginal lake. This lake also spilled through the Dover Straits,
the resulting megafloods enlarging the gap; during high sea-level periods Britain would henceforth be
an island.
The implications of such striking geographical changes for plant and animal (including human)
migration are profound, resulting, among other things, in the impoverishment of the British flora and
fauna during warm periods like today, but providing a major routeway during glacial periods. In
addition, the virtually instantaneous release of huge volumes of freshwater from the megafloods into
the Atlantic Ocean could have triggered changes in oceanic circulation which, in turn, could have
affected the climate of the whole North Atlantic region.
The Quaternary North Sea Basin: infill history and sedimentary processes
Dag Ottesen1, Christine Batchelor2, Julian Dowdeswell3, Helge Løseth4
1
Geological Survey of Norway; 2Norwegian University of Science and Technology; 3University of
Cambridge; 4Equinor
Based on a large database of regional 2D seismic lines, we have mapped the Base of the Quaternary
of the entire North Sea Basin between 52°N and 62°N. In addition several internal reflectors of the
Quaternary sequence have been mapped so the infill history of the basin during the last 3 million years
can be shown. The infill processes of the northern basin and the central and southern basin were very
different. The southern and central basin were filled in by a large deltaic unit mainly from southeast,
east and northeast by large rivers from northern Germany, Poland and the Baltic area as well as from
southern Norway and Sweden. Most of the southern basin was filled in by 1.5 Ma. The remaining
central basin were then filled in by c. 1.0 Ma.,
The northern North Sea basin (north of 59°N) was filled in by glacigenic debris flows deposited by an
ice sheet covering most of Norway and parts of Sweden. These sediments are part of a 1000-km long
progradational system extending from Stavanger in southwestern Norway (59°N) to the Lofoten area
(68°N) in northern Norway. The ice sheet built out the shelf outside western Norway up to 150 km
from c. 2.75 Ma with sediment thicknesses up to 1500 m.
After the northern North Sea basin was filled in by sediments around 1 million years ago, the
Norwegian Channel Ice Stream started to operate and carved out the 800-km long and 100 km wide
Norwegian Channel during the last few glaciations.
Palaeogeographic change in response to glacial/interglacial cycles: Middle
and Upper Pleistocene stratigraphy of the southern North Sea
Stephen Eaton1, David Hodgson1, Natasha Barlow1, Estelle Mortimer1, Claire Mellett2
1
University of Leeds; 2Wessex Archaeology
The Middle to Late Pleistocene (MIS19 to MIS2) period is characterised by considerable global climatic
instability, with repeated cycles of glaciation and high amplitude relative sea-level changes. Recently
acquired industrial quality high resolution seismic, core and geotechnical data from the southern
North Sea form a valuable archive of mid-latitude palaeogeographic change during this period. Three
major stratigraphic units have been identified using seismic mapping, seismic facies analysis, core
logging and interpretation of cone penetration test (CPT) data. The lowermost stratigraphic unit
(approximately MIS 19 to MIS 13) is predominantly fluviatile and overlies the marine deltaic
successions characterising the Early Pleistocene. Channel-fills within this unit are orientated
approximately north-south and northeast-southwest, and display variable channel fill architecture,
and provide direct evidence for large-scale Middle Pleistocene fluvial networks North of 52° in the
southern North Sea. These fluvial networks are interpreted to be a consequence of the evolution and
increasing influence of mainland European and British river systems in response to climatic changes.
A series of north-south trending tunnel valley-fills, provide evidence for subglacial conditions at this
location, and are thought to have formed during the Anglian Stage glaciation (MIS12). There appears
to be a sedimentary hiatus with sediments from MIS 5d and 4 then dominating the survey area. These
deposits are predominantly sheet-like and composed of silts and clays with indications of iron sulphide
and marine shells supporting a low energy, restricted marine environment. Dune-scale bedforms and
variation in the geomechanical properties (CPT) of the fill provide evidence for changes in the rate of
relative sea-level fall and the evolution of a dynamic and complex coastal landscape during this time.
Analysis and interpretation of the southern North Sea Quaternary stratigraphy using this high
resolution dataset provides critical information informing ice sheet extent, landscape response to
glacial/interglacial cycles and sea-level fluctuations.
Late Quaternary geological processes from the southeast Skagerrak – a
transnational geological feature
Matthew Owen1, Nicky Witt1, Paul Knutz1, Katrine Andresen2, Jørgen O. Leth1, Zyad Al-Hamdani1
1
Geological Survey of Denmark and Greenland; 2Aarhus University
The Skagerrak has been a vital component of the northwest European geo-system since its formation
during the Quaternary glaciations. During glacial periods it acts as a major ice stream for the
Fennoscandian ice sheet and during interglacials it is the deepest element of the North Sea and a
major sediment sink. The Skagerrak is also an interesting case of a feature cut by national boundaries,
with significant portions located in the Norwegian, Swedish and Danish Exclusive Economic Zones.
These boundaries are clearly visible on the area’s bathymetric map with the Danish sector notable for
lower resolution data. We begin to address this knowledge gap using high-resolution marine
geophysical data to interpret a large area in the southeast Skagerrak. We map a number of different
geological features that are diagnostic of different stages of the area's late Quaternary evolution.
These include deeper water seabed features such as contourite waves, eroded ridges and pockmarks;
as well as a glacial surface that is buried by up to 50 m of post-glacial material, and several stratigraphic
units that are truncated. In shallower waters, uplifted outcropping units show variation in strike from
northeast to southeast. These features provide evidence of different bottom current regimes
operating in glacial and interglacial periods. These different regimes are driven by the switch in the
Skagerrak's situation from a glacial embayment to a deep-water trough in the North Sea and reflect
the changing oceanographic circulation from glacial, to early Holocene and, following the initiation of
the Jutland Current, the mid to late Holocene.
On the origin of Late Quaternary arctic marine faunas: implications for
landscape evolution in the southern North Sea Basin during the Late
Pleistocene
Frank Wesselingh1, Freek Busschers2, Bram Langeveld3, Sytze van Heteren2, Thijs van Kolfschoten4,
Erica van Hees5, Wim Kuijper1, Tom Meijer1, Gareth Davies6
Naturalis Biodiversity Center, Leiden; 2TNO – Geological Survey of the Netherlands; 3Natural History
Museum Rotterdam; 4Leiden University; 5Archol Leiden; 6VU University Amsterdam
1
Arctic marine fossils such as Walrus, Beluga and cold mollusk species are well known from the
southern North Sea Basin, collected by fisherman and from dredge spoils and coastal sand
nourishments. Yet their stratigraphic position and depositional context remain hitherto poorly
understood. Radiocarbon ages for the arctic marine mammal remains indicate a late MIS3 age but the
necessary associated submergence of the North Sea is in disagreement with the prevailing view of low
global sea levels at the time. Likely, the 14C ages are ghost ages resulting from bacterial diagenesis.
The presence of two in situ high-boreal to arctic mollusk faunas, one from the Oyster Grounds and
one from subaquatic sand pits used for the construction of latest Rotterdam Harbor extension
(Maasvlakte II), suggest that multiple arctic marine intervals occurred during MIS5 and, potentially,
during early MIS3. We report initial age estimates for these cold intervals based on a combination of
OSL datings, a Uranium series age and regional correlations. These marine phases, which need to be
corroborated by further research, are crucial to understand the overall evolution and preservation of
North Sea landscapes during the Late Quaternary.
Locality of Late Pleistocene cold boreal and arctic marine faunas from the southern North Sea.
The evolution of the Last Interglacial North Sea reconstructed using
preserved wave- and tide-dominated paleo-estuarine infills on the Belgian
continental shelf
Maikel De Clercq1,2, David García-Moreno3, Tine Missiaen4, Mieke Mathys5, Marc De Batist1
Ghent University; 2Jan De Nul; 3RBINS – Geological Survey of Belgium; 4Flanders Marine Institute;
5
IMDC
1
The relatively smooth morphology of the Southern North Sea (SNS) shelf is greatly influenced by Late
Pleistocene eustatic sea-level changes. Over this period, relatively small sea-level variations
potentially caused kilometres of shoreline displacements and left behind a fragmentary sedimentary
record that can be used for reconstructing submerged paleolandscapes. The Last Interglacial sea-level
rise in the SNS is probably one of the best studied Pleistocene sea-level changes and is featured in
many Last Interglacial sea level and glacio-isostasy studies. Its reconstruction is mainly based on
sedimentary contacts in near-coastal and estuarine deposits preserved within incised valley systems
close to the present coastline, which provide detailed information about the final stages of the sealevel rise and the subsequent high-stand. Sedimentary evidence of the early stages of the
transgression, however, are rare in the SNS. These early transgressive sediments provide important
clues to understand the drowning history of the SNS immediately after deglaciation and its impact on
the biosphere and human migration routes across drowning landmasses prior to final inundation. The
Palaeo-Scheldt Valley (PSV) on the Belgian shelf extends from the present-day onshore Flemish Valley
downstream to the submerged Axial Channel trunk valley. After the Last Interglacial inundation of the
Axial Channel the lower reaches of the PSV transformed into a wave-dominated estuary. Here, the
typical central basin clays are preserved. The continued sea-level rise rapidly transgressed the Belgian
shelf. In its upper reaches, close to the present-day shoreline, the PSV has the typical funnel-shaped
morphology and tide-dominated sandy sedimentary sequences (comparable to the present-day
Western Scheldt). Pollen analysis and OSL-dating across the PSV suggest that the transition from a
shallow embayment to a macrotidal epeiric sea must have occurred at the transition of the EarlyMiddle part of the Last Interglacial.
One network may hide others – toward a comprehensive scenario for
Neogene superimposed valley networks along the English Channel
Fabien Paquet, Isabel Thinon, Eric Lasseur, Justine Briais
BRGM – French Geological Survey
The English Channel has been an area of intense geological investigation for decades, spanning various
subjects such as structural and basin evolution between variscan and alpine orogenic cycles or
sediment transport over a wide platform under tidal and storm currents. Among these subjects, one
specific and noticeable feature of the English Channel is the occurrence of a complex network of
channels with clear morphological expression at the seabed. Since the beginning of the 20th century,
and more pragmatically since the 1970s and the development of high-resolution seismic acquisition,
this network has been the focus of several studies that proposed various scenarii for its origin and age.
The existence of two superimposed networks had already been proposed in the late 70’s by Alduc.
Since 2007, in the framework of the geological mapping of the French continental shelf, BRGM and
collaborators (University of Caen Basse-Normandie/UMR M2C; University of Lille 1/UMR LOG,…)
acquired a dense grid of very high resolution marine seismic data. Interpretation of these data (i)
confirms that several networks are superimposed, and (ii) details the real complexity and discontinuity
of the older network(s) associated to the “Fosses de la Manche” system. Finally, thanks to high quality
oil exploration seismic data, we were able to reveal a local unexpected increase of bedrock incision
and associated sedimentary fill up to c. 350 m. These observations and subsequent implications for
networks origin (fluvial or tidal) and development are discussed with respect to regional geological
settings and controlling parameters. Their significance in terms of source-to-sink features is a key
aspect as the English Channel is certainly an important zone of sediment transfer during Neogene,
collecting from a large catchment and delivering to Western Approaches, Celtic Sea and Bay of Biscay
abyssal plains. Drilling selected targets to provide groundtruthing now sounds like the obvious step.
Opening of the Dover Strait: Constraints on landscape evolution from high
resolution sonars and sub-bottom data
Sanjeev Gupta1, Jenny S. Collier1, David García-Moreno2, Francesca Oggioni1, Kris Vanneste3, Alain
Trentesaux4, Koen Verbeeck3, Wim Versteeg5, Hervé Jomard6, Thierry Camelbeeck3, Marc De Batist2
1
Imperial College London; 2Ghent University; 3Royal Observatory of Belgium; 4University of Lille;
5
Flanders Marine Institute; 6French Radioprotection and Nuclear Safety Institute
Our understanding of the late Quaternary evolution of the English Channel has significantly advanced
in the past 10-15 years, primarily through the results of new marine surveys. Here, we summarise the
results of recent collaborative efforts using high-resolution sonar-derived bathymetry and seismic
reflection data to understand the inception of the Strait of Dover and its implications for NW European
palaeogeographic evolution. Prominent landforms, either buried or preserved at the seafloor, provide
important constraints on the processes that led to the opening and present-day configuration of the
Dover Strait. Sub-bottom records in the Strait reveal erosional landforms, the Fosse Dangeard, which
form a remarkable set of isolated, sediment-infilled depressions that are deeply incised into bedrock.
They consist of several interconnected palaeo-depressions that are sub-circular to elliptical in
planform, <4 kilometres in diameter and up to 100 m in depth. These features are clustered along the
projected trend of the onshore Chalk escarpment that likely extended from Britain to France and we
interpret as giant plunge pools formed by vertical drilling into bedrock by waterfalls plunging over the
escarpment lip. The morphology and spatial distribution of the Fosses Dangeard strongly suggest that
they arise by plunge pool erosion generated at the base of north-eastward retreating waterfalls. Their
infills comprise internal erosional surfaces that provide evidence for the occurrence of several
erosional episodes following their initial incision. The Fosse Dangeard represent an excellent target
for future drilling to constrain the detailed processes, palaeoenvironments and chronology of the
evolution of drainage systems in NW Europe. The modern submarine landscape in the region is
dominated by the Lobourg Channel, a prominent bedrock-carved valley that cuts across the Strait. We
discuss the various hypotheses for the origin of these distinct landforms and consider their
implications for the evolution of the North Sea-Channel palaeodrainage system.
Evolution of southern North Sea drainage systems during Middle-Late
Pleistocene marine lowstands
David García-Moreno1, Maikel De Clercq2,3, Vasileios Chademenos2, Tine Missiaen4, Marc De Batist2
RBINS – Geological Survey of Belgium; 2Ghent University; 3Jan De Nul; 4Flanders Marine Institute
1
During Middle-Late Pleistocene glaciations, the sea level dropped, exposing large parts of the currently
submerged North Sea and English Channel areas for thousands of years. Therefore, north-western
European drainage systems extended across these areas, forming river systems and lakes.
Reconstructions of the southern North Sea palaeodrainage systems are mainly based on the study of
on-land palaeovalleys and a prominent palaeovalley system carved along the English Channel.
However, the continuation of the Channel palaeovalleys across the southern North Sea and their
connection with Middle-Late Pleistocene north European palaeodrainage systems are largely
unknown. The present study aims to better characterise the drainage systems that traversed the
southern North Sea area during Middle-Late Pleistocene marine lowstands by mapping and analysing
the morphologies and interrelationships of the palaeovalleys carved into its seafloor. To do so, we
have gathered an extensive geophysical dataset from the Belgian and British Continental shelves.
The analysis of the geophysical data shows that the Rhine-Meuse and Thames palaeovalleys converge
into a major NE-SW-oriented palaeochannel (i.e., the Axial-Lobourg Channel), which connects the
southern North Sea basin to the Channel palaeovalleys. Our investigation has also revealed the
occurrence of several major valley incisions and watercourse migrations along these palaeovalleys.
This corroborates the occurrence of multiple reactivations of the southern North Sea drainage system
during the various Middle-Late Pleistocene lowstands. The most recent of these carved a prominent
NNE–SSW-oriented inner channel within the Axial–Lobourg Channel, the morphology of which has
been associated with the occurrence of megaflood events in the Dover Strait. The orientation and
extent of this inner channel suggest that the intense fluvial/flood erosion that carved it may be linked
to the south-westward diversion of northern Dutch and German palaeo-rivers during the Last Glacial
Maximum.
The impact of Middle Pleistocene glacial lake-outburst floods on the
meltwater-drainage system of northern central Europe
Jörg Lang1, Petteri Alho2, Elina Kasvi2, Nils Goseberg3, Jutta Winsemann1
1
Leibniz University Hannover; 2University of Turku; 3TU Braunschweig
During the Middle Pleistocene glaciations numerous ice-dammed lakes formed along the
southwestern margin of the Fennoscandian ice sheets. The repeated lake-outburst floods from these
lakes strongly impacted the meltwater-drainage systems and the post-glacial fluvial evolution in
northern Central Europe by providing an efficient drainage network, although these ice-dammed lakes
were comparatively small. During ice-margin retreat, the glacial lakes successively drained westwards.
While the proximal lake-outburst flood pathways are comparatively well constrained by erosional
features like deep plunge pools, trench-like channels, megaflutes, scour pools and streamlined hills,
the distal flood pathways into the southern North Sea Basin are more uncertain. In the distal flood
areas, the flood waves rapidly spread out and the flows decelerated. Flow simulations imply that the
floods followed approximately east-west to south-east to north-west trending routes through the
central and northern Netherlands into the North Sea Basin (Winsemann et al., 2016; Lang et al., 2019).
However, the use of the present-day DEM for flow simulations might affect the modelled flood routing
and inundation area, because it does not entirely represent the pre-flood topography. When the
glacial lake-outburst floods entered the North Sea Basin, the added volume of water may have raised
the lake-level of the North Sea Lake and contributed to the overspill, dam break and drainage of the
North Sea Lake via the Strait of Dover.
References:
Winsemann, J, Alho, P., Laamanen, L., Goseberg, N., Lang, J. & Klostermann, J. (2016): Flow dynamics,
sedimentation and erosion of glacial lake outburst floods along the Middle Pleistocene Scandinavian
ice sheet (northern Central Europe). Boreas, 45,260-283.
Lang, J., Alho, P., Kasvi, E., Goseberg, N. & Winsemann, J. (2019): Impact of Middle Pleistocene
(Saalian) glacial lake-outburst floods on the meltwater-drainage pathways in northern central Europe:
insights from 2D numerical flood simulation. Quaternary Science Reviews 209, 82-99.
Fosse drilling needed
Alain Trentesaux, Delphine Buguet, Jean-Yves Reynaud
University of Lille
Understanding the opening of Dover Strait is a fascinating challenge, that requires renewed research
on the stratigraphic “black boxes” of the Quaternary of the Southern North Sea to the Western
Approaches of the English Channel. From high-resolution seismic profiles, the best candidates are the
large deep troughs known as the “Fosses Dangeard” located between Calais and Dover. Little
lithological information is available on their infill. Long coring (61.2 m) was performed prior the
Channel tunnel digging operations in the mid 70’s, that delivered microfauna and pollens within the
first 58.8 m of soft sediments. These deposits indicate that shallow marine (possibly estuarine), coldwater conditions prevailed before the very early post-Glacial. In the 2000’s, vibrocores at the surface
of these deeps were performed. Only one was able to crosscut the cobble pavement that covers the
seabed in the strait. It is 95 cm long and presents well-laminated silty clays, with varying amount of
nannofossil-rich ooze. XRD analyses indicate a lithology not much different from most other upper
Quaternary deposits from the southern North Sea or Eastern English Channel. The cobble lag is likely
related, as in most other places of the English Channel, to a transgressive lag while the laminated muds
are tentatively interpreted as glacio-lacustrine varves. These results can be put in perspective of
seismic studies of other deeps of the English Channel, namely the Hurd Deep where proglacial fluviolacustrine deltas might be preserved. There is a rising idea that the Fosses Dangeard could be giant
plunge pools (jökulhlaups), which is supported by the complex 3D cut-and-fill architecture that was
shown by the more detailed seismic profiles collected in the 2000’s. However, a much deeper coring
is now required to get the complete picture, and especially to refine the timing of this multistorey
record of the Geological Brexit.
Closeup view of the CM-02-03-01 core (scale in cm from sea floor).
Anomalous buried scour hollows in the Borssele wind farm site
Bart Meijninger
TNO – Geological Survey of the Netherlands
With the development of the Dutch Borssele wind farm offshore, a wealth of geological, geotechnical
and geophysical data from reconnaissance surveys has become available to the public. This presents
a unique opportunity for scientists: the high-quality dataset provides a detailed insight into the
seafloor dynamics and unravels the Quaternary, Neogene and Paleogene stratigraphy of the Southern
Bight of the North Sea.
Several distinct sediment-infilled depressions were identified from the 2015 survey data of the
Borssele wind farm and interpreted as buried scour hollows. Their occurrence in the subsurface was
till now not known in this part the North Sea. The scour hollows in the Borssele wind farm have
asymmetric funnel-shaped forms and incised up to 50 m deep into the underlying Neogene-Paleogene
strata. A borehole was drilled in the center of one of these scour hollows and several samples were
acquired from its sediment infill. The sediments comprised mostly sand. Palynological analysis of two
clay samples from the base of the scour hollow indicated reworked Neogene-Paleogene assemblages,
but did not reveal a clear age of this feature. Given the stratigraphic position of the scour hollow with
respect to the units above and below a Pleistocene age (possibly Eemian to Weichselian) is assumed.
Similar sediment-infilled depressions have been identified further south in the Southern Bight
(offshore Belgium) and in the Strait of Dover, as well as onshore in the area of London (e.g. Liu et al.,
1993; Banks et al., 2015; Gupta et al., 2017). The age and origin of these depressions is subject to
ongoing discussion. In general, the depressions appear to be located within paleo-fluvial channels,
hence a fluvial origin is assumed. The geomorphology (reflecting competence of the underlying
dipping strata) and subsurface conditions, such as ground water flow and permafrost, may also have
played a role in their development. The depressions have been interpreted as plunge pools related to
large scale drainage possibly from a proglacial lake in the Southern North Sea during one or multiple
events in the Pleistocene (Collier, 2017: an ice-age catastrophic megaflood?). Another hypothesis is
that the depressions have formed by tidal scouring (Liu et al., 1993).
With thanks to Ørsted, TNO-GDN received sample material from this borehole to further investigate
the age and origin of the scour hollows in its context of the regional geology and paleogeomorphology.
Glacial erratics on the Belgian Continental Shelf: analysis, origin and
transportation mechanisms
Maikel De Clercq1,2, David García-Moreno3, Tine Missiaen4, Marc De Batist1
Ghent University; 2Jan De Nul; 3RBINS – Geological Survey of Belgium; 4Flanders Marine Institute
1
Scattered on a submerged Late Saalian river terrace on the Belgian shelf lies a unique collection of
erratic clasts ranging from several centimetres to three meters in diameter. Petrographic analysis of
these clasts determined a Scottish Grampian Highland and British East Coast provenance. The
recurrent occupation of the British Ice Sheet since the Middle Pleistocene has transported a
heterogeneous collection of bedrock material along the western margins of the North Sea and
deposited them as moraines. During the Last Glacial it is hypothesised that a proglacial lake, enclosed
by the British and Scandinavian Ice Sheets, existed in the Southern North Sea from 26 to 18.7 ka. We
hypothesise that during the final deglaciation lake-level variations from meltwater input and ice-front
destabilisation initiated ice calving releasing icebergs carrying scoured bedrock material into this lake.
The meltwater input and disturbance of the lake by calving initiated several discharge events into the
Atlantic Ocean through the Axial and English Channels. At the downstream Bay of Biscay, five such
large-scale freshwater discharge events were recorded and dated between 30.7 and 16.7 ka
(Toucanne et al., 2015). Three of them occur during the lifespan of the proglacial lake. We infer that
during drainage the icebergs released into the lake were transported downstream through the Axial
Channel towards the Dover Strait. On the Belgian shelf the maximum width of the Axial Channel
extends up to a higher positioned Late Saalian terrace located at c. -35 m LAT. Here, the terrace bends
westwards into a position nearly perpendicular to the discharge direction. Upon discharge, the higher
floodplain flooded by the lake discharge thereby grounding the icebergs. When the stranded icebergs
melted, they released the scoured material that the British Ice Sheet picked up from the parent
bedrock and moraines leaving them scattered far from their parent rocks.
The tunnel valleys of the central and northern North Sea (56°N – 62°N):
Distribution, Characteristics and Generations
Margaret Stewart1, Dag Ottesen2, Marco Bronner2, Christine Batchelor2
1
British Geological Survey; 2Geological Survey of Norway
Tunnel valleys are km-scale linear landforms formed subglacially beneath large ice sheets. In the
British and Norwegian sectors of the North Sea, offshore tunnel valleys are associated with multiple
Quaternary glaciations. In this study, we use 2D and 3D seismic reflection data, and magnetic data, to
map more than a thousand buried tunnel valleys in the central and northern North Sea. The tunnel
valleys are generally present from the seabed to depths of around 500 metres, in a study area of 180
000 km2 from 56°N to around 62°N. Buried tunnel valleys are well-imaged in seismic reflection data,
particularly in horizontal timeslices in 3D seismic data. In magnetic data, the tunnel valleys appear as
small scale magnetic lows, likely due to their infill being less compacted and potentially more porous
than the surroundings.
This work provides the most extensive study of tunnel valleys in the region to date, and also finds the
longest tunnel valley recorded in the region, with a number of large meandering tunnel valleys
extending for more than 150 km. We also find tunnel valleys further north in the North Sea than
previously reported, as well as a number of isolated tunnel valleys extending towards and into the
Norwegian Channel. As reported by other studies in the region, the apparently extensive networks of
buried valleys are found to be comprised of cross-cutting generations. In four study areas, we find
between 3 and 6 generations, and relate them to potential ice sheet configurations.
Tunnel valley density in the central and northern North Sea.
Paleolandscapes and ice-marginal subsurface landforms in the German sector
of the southeastern North Sea imaged by closely spaced high-resolution 2D
multi-channel reflection seismics
Arne Lohrberg, Sebastian Krastel, Tim Willems, Gianna Persichini, Klaus Schwarzer
Kiel University
Ice sheet dynamics and ice margins in the southeastern North Sea are still poorly constrained, mainly
due to the lack of high-resolution seismic data. We collected approx. 1000 km of 2D high-resolution
multi-channel reflection seismic data close to Germany's west coast between the Amrum bank and
the Eider valley in summer 2017 as part of the project Nordfriesland-Süd in order to map and analyze
the shelf architecture. Despite a small acoustic source (Micro-GI Gun primary volume 0.1 l) and a sandy
shallow seafloor, penetration exceeds 350 meters below seafloor (mbsf) with a resolution in the meter
range.
The dense grid of high-resolution seismic data allowed us to identify and trace multiple generations
of tunnel valleys incised under an ice sheet that covered our survey area during glaciations. Deep
buried tunnel valleys (>2.5 km wide, >200 mbsf deep) incised into inclined Neogene and Paleogene
strata, which have been deformed by salt tectonics. We found an extensive set of glacial push
moraines stacked to form an imbricate fan, documenting a highly dynamic ice sheet margin. These
massive thrust features point northwest and westwards. They are imaged on top of undisturbed
deeper strata, thus forming a perfect décollement. A dominant westward updipping erosional surface
intersected by tunnel valleys is found in the shallow subsurface (20 - 70 mbsf) in the central to eastern
part of the survey area; it was most likely formed during a pre-Weichselian glacial advance. Its western
limit indicates the most westwards extent of the ice sheet.
The identified features document the glacial history of this area and allow us to infer models for its
highly dynamic glacial history. Combining the findings leads us to believe that the data document an
arcuate ice lobe that advanced over the survey area during several glaciation and deglaciation cycles.
Deposition of proglacial sediments along an active ice margin during the Last
Glacial Maximum, Dogger Bank, southern central North Sea
Kirstin Johnson1, Emrys Phillips1, Carol Cotterill1, Leo James2
1
British Geological Survey, 2RPS Energy Ltd
High-resolution seismic data from the Dogger Bank in the southern central North Sea has revealed
that the Dogger Bank Formation records a complex history of ice-marginal to proglacial sedimentation
and penecontemporaneous, large-scale, glacitectonic deformation during the Last Glacial Maximum.
The study site presented here is located along the margin of the Weichselian British and Irish Ice Sheet
and Fennoscandian Ice Sheet.
The resulting glacigenic landsystem and sedimentary sequences reveal the presence of a number of
sedimentological features including meltwater channels, outwash fans and plains, desiccation
surfaces and lacustrine systems, as well as a plethora of glacitectonic arcuate thrust-block moraines.
Here we focus on the development of the meltwater channel systems, outwash flood sheets and fan
systems which formed during the northward retreat of the ice sheet across Dogger Bank. The fans are
up to 2.5km wide and comprise sediment packages (50m thick) with inclined reflectors. They are
interpreted as forming an ice marginal apron system occupying a low lying sedimentary basin formed
between the larger, higher relief moraines located within the southern margin of the Dogger Bank.
Large channels up to 1km wide and between 30m and 70m deep have been identified incised into a
thick (40m) sequence of outwash sediments. These sediments exhibit varying degrees of deformation,
linked to a history of active retreat of the ice margin. The complex internal architecture of the channels
indicate that they record several periods of sedimentation separated by prominent erosive surfaces.
Desiccation surfaces are preserved within both the channels and laterally extensive outwash plains,
indicating several periods of intense periglacial weathering (drying, alteration) occurred during
deglaciation. This sedimentary assemblage therefore records a complex history of deposition,
meltwater release and channel incision separated by phases of periglacial weathering and
glacitectonic deformation during the Weichselian deglaciation of the Dogger Bank.
The effect of boundary conditions on morphometric parameters of tunnel
valleys in the North Sea
Mattijs Vollenberg1,2, Fiammetta Mondino1, Andrea Moscariello2
1
Geneva Earth Resources SA; 2University of Geneva
The seabed of the shallow epicontinental North Sea has been sculpted by multiple glacial phases
during the late Pleistocene, leaving behind a large amount of tunnel valleys. Although many studies
aimed to map these erosional features, only a few focussed on collecting and analysing their
morphological properties. Through a literature revue, existing data were gathered and collected in a
database, aiming to analyse and determine the interdependency between morphometric aspects,
such as length, depth, width, density and spacing. Parallelly, more than 1000 tunnel valleys were
analysed to determine the effect of diverse boundary conditions (faults, geology, salt diapirs, ice-sheet
orientation) on morphometrical and geographical parameters. Preliminary results show that although
the length doesn’t present any correlation with any other parameter, width and depth of tunnel
valleys seems to be strongly interdependent. Regarding the boundary conditions, half of the tunnel
valleys are parallel to the regional structural trends in the North-Western North Sea. Fault presence
however seems to have no impact on the length of the features. Concerning geology, differences in
lithology show the impact of erodibility, mainly controlled by grain size, density and cohesiveness.
Tunnel valleys in the Neogene shales are less parallel to the faults, shorter, less dense and less spaced
than tunnel valleys in the Paleogene sandstones. In conclusion, the screening work carried out to date
indicates that all these factors have a certain degree of influence on tunnel valleys and none of these
alone can be indicated as the main predisposing condition and driving factor controlling the formation
of tunnel valleys. The examination of the available data rather suggests that most likely other factors
should be considered such as glaciological parameters i.e. ice thickness variation, pressure gradient
and flow properties of subglacial meltwater and its drainage network organization, as well as the
geomechanic properties of the bedrock and the influence of changes of them trough time and space
during alternations of temperature values (e.g. freezing vs thawing) and pressure (grounding vs
detachment) at the interface ice-bedrock.
The examination of all of them therefore may help in discerning which ones are likely to be the driving
mechanisms controlling the genesis and resulting morphometric parameters of tunnel valleys.
Overview map of the North Sea presenting tunnel valleys, faults, geology, glaciation limits and ice
vectors. These data have been compiled from Huuse (2000), Boulton & Hagdorn (2006), and The
Millenium Atlas.
The last glacial cycle in the North Sea Basin: research highlights from the
BRITICE-CHRONO project
Louise Callard1, David Roberts2, David Evans2, Chris Clark3, Colm O'Cofaigh2, Heather Stewart4,
Dayton Dove4, Elena Grimoldi2, Mark Bateman3, Richard Chiverrell5, BRITICE-CHRONO consortium3
1
Newcastle University; 2Durham University; 3University of Sheffield; 4British Geological Survey;
5
University of Liverpool
Over the past 6 years researchers on the BRITICE-CHRONO consortium project have being working
towards constraining the timing and pattern of retreat of the last British-Irish Ice sheet (BIIS). During
this time, a systematic dating programme focusing on eight transects spanning the marine to
terrestrial transition has added 639 geochronometric ages that further constrain the BIIS. Of the eight
regions studied, the largest was the North Sea Basin (NSB), known as Transect 2. This region is
particular complex as it was overrun at various times by both the BIIS and the Fennoscandian Ice Sheet
(FIS) during the last glacial cycle resulting in periods of ice sheet coalescence, decoupling, marine
inundation and the turning on and off of individual ice streams.
In 2015, over 3500 km of marine seismic data and 85 vibrocores were collected on board the RV James
Cook, research cruise JC123. Since then, 36 radiocarbon dates and 7 OSL samples from cores collect
offshore, combined with OSL dating from onshore, provides a NSB-wide glacial and deglacial
stratigraphic and chronological history as well as evidence of past sea-level change in the region. This
contribution provides an overview and research highlights of the work conducted in the NSB by
BRITICE-CHRONO. However, there are still unanswered questions and uncertainties in the glacialdeglacial history of the NSB that warrant further investigation.
Seismic interpretation and structural restoration of the Heligoland
glaciotectonic thrust-fault complex: deformation during a pre-Elsterian ice
advance into the southern North Sea Basin?
Jutta Winsemann1, Hannes Koopmann2, David C. Tanner1, Rüdiger Lutz3, Jörg Lang1, Christian
Brandes1, Christoph Gaedicke3
1
Leibniz University Hannover; 2COWI A/S Velje; 3German Federal Institute for Geosciences and
Natural Resources
The Heligoland glaciotectonic thrust-fault complex forms part of a large belt of glaciotectonic
complexes that stretches from offshore Denmark via northern Germany to Poland. Multi-channel
high-resolution 2D seismic reflection data, acquired north of Heligoland, show a huge thrust-fault
complex in the upper 300 ms TWT (ca. 240 m) of the seismic data. This thrust-fault complex consists
of Neogene and Pleistocene sediments and covers an area of 350 km². The total length of the
glaciotectonic thrust complex is approximately 15 km. The thrust faults share a common detachment
surface, located at a depth of 250 to 300 ms (TWT) (ca. 200-240 m) below sea level, at the base of
upper Middle Miocene or Upper Miocene deposits, above the Mid-Miocene Unconformity (MMU).
Restored sections reveal the shortening of the complex along the detachment to have been on
average 23%. The detachment surface may either indicate a pronounced intra-formational rheological
boundary (e.g., clay or an extensive sand sheet with overpressurized pore water) or the depth of
permafrost and the boundary between frozen and unfrozen sediment. The determined ice movement
direction from east-southeast to southeast suggests deformation by a surging ice lobe or fast moving
ice-stream from the Baltic region. The chronospatial relationship of the thrust-fault complex and
adjacent Elsterian tunnel valleys implies a pre- or early Elsterian age of the glaciotectonic complex. A
second deformation phase probably occurred during the Warthe (1) ice advance. During this advance,
the Elsterian tunnel-valley fills that were incised into the glaciotectonic complex were partly
deformed.
Reference
Winsemann, J., Koopmann, H., Tanner, D.C., Lutz, R., Lang, J., Brandes, C., Gaedicke, C. (in review):
Seismic interpretation and structural restoration of the Heligoland glaciotectonic thrust-fault complex:
implications for a two-fold deformation during (pre)-Elsterian to Warthian ice advances into the
southern North Sea Basin. Quaternary Science Reviews.
Glacial deformation in the eastern German North Sea – from shallow
fracturing to large-scale thrusting
Volkhard Spiess, Hanno Keil, Noemi Fekete
University of Bremen
Northern hemisphere glaciations significantly influenced sediment deposition in Northern European
coastal areas and continental margins. Sea level lowering, build-up of thick ice covers, ice movement,
subglacial erosion and the modification of the drainage network caused major changes in depositional
environment between interglacial and glacial periods. In this respect, glacial deformation of the
subsurface may be driven hydraulically by subglacial valley formation or mechanically by loading,
which may lead to fracturing, and by thrusting, where larger blocks are relocated.
Before the mid-Pleistocene transition, the North Sea Basin was supposedly not buried by the
Scandinavian Ice Sheet exposed to major glaciations after. But only Elsterian and early Saalian
glaciations covered the German North Sea with a significant ice thickness, during late Saalian and
Weichselian periods, the ice margin was presumably located near the Danish coast.
During the last decade, Bremen University had collected large multichannel seismic data sets in the
German North Sea in various cooperative projects, which will be used to further characterize the
depositional setting (see Keil et al.). It will be of particular interest to find out more about the role of
glacial advances for the subsurface materials and properties, also because of the need of geotechnical
characterization of soils for offshore installations as wind parks.
Here we present examples from the area north of Helgoland, which reveal different types of
presumably glacial deformation. Major thrust blocks were spatially surveyed to determine the degree
of deformation and rotation and to measure their orientation. Also, some structures previously
identified as subglacial valleys are discussed with respect to a possible interpretation as rotational
thrust blocks. The shallowest section of North Sea sediment of several 10’s of meters seem to mostly
lack coherent stratification, which we attribute, at least partially, to a postdepositional fracturing due
to glacial loading.
Ice marginal dynamics of the last British-Irish Ice Sheet in the southern North
Sea: ice limits, timing and the influence of the Dogger Bank
David Roberts
Durham University
The southern North Sea is a particularly important area for understanding the behaviour of the BritishIrish Ice Sheet (BIIS) during the last glacial cycle. It preserves a record of the maximum extent of the
eastern sector of the BIIS as well as evidence for multiple different ice flow phases and the dynamic
re-organisation of the BIIS. This work explores the origin and age of the Dogger Bank (DB); re-assesses
the extent and age of the glaciogenic deposits across the shallow areas of the North Sea adjacent to
the Dogger Bank and; re-examines the dynamic behaviour of the BIIS in the southern North Sea
between 30 – 19 ka.
New sedimentary, geophysical and geochronological data collected for the Britice-Chrono project
suggests DB is composed predominantly by glaciolacustrine sediment deposited between 31.6 - 25.8
ka. Following its formation, the western end of the Dogger lake was overridden with initial ice override
and retreat northwards back across the Dogger lake complete by 23.1 ka. This resulted in widespread
compressive glaciotectonism of the lake sediments and the formation of thrust moraine complexes.
Along the northern edge of the DB moraines are on-lapped by later phase glaciolacustrine and marine
sediments but do not show evidence of subsequent ice override. The seafloor to the west/southwest
of the DB records several later phases of ice advance and retreat as the North Sea Lobe (NSL) flowed
between the DB and the Yorkshire/Lincolnshire coast. New OSL ages limit the arrival of the BIIS on the
Norfolk coast to 22.8 – 21.5 ka, after which multiple till sheets and moraines on the seafloor mark
northwards retreat of the NSL. This pattern of behaviour is broadly synchronous with the terrestrial
sedimentary along the Yorkshire coast which relate to post Dimlington Stadial NSL oscillation and
retreat (~ 21.5 - 19ka).
Glacitectonic evidence of ice lobe interaction across Dogger Bank (southern
central North Sea) during the Last Glacial Maximum
Emrys Phillips1, Kirstin Johnson1, Rachael Ellen1, Carol Cotterill1, Leo James2
1
British Geological Survey; 2RPS Energy Ltd
High-resolution seismic data from the Dogger Bank has revealed that the Dogger Bank Formation
records a complex history of sedimentation and penecontemporaneous, large-scale, ice-marginal to
proglacial glacitectonic deformation. These processes led to the development of a complex
assemblage of glacial landforms and sediments which record the interplay between two lobes of the
Weichselian ice sheet which occupied the North Sea basin during the Late Glacial Maximum. The
“Dogger Bank lobe” advanced from the N/NW with its subsequent active northward retreat resulting
in the development of a complex assemblage of arcuate thrust-block moraines (“Dogger Bank
moraine”) composed of highly folded and thrusted lower Dogger Bank sediments (c. 40-50m thick).
These large glacitectonic landforms (200m-15km across; >30km long) are separated by low-lying
sedimentary basins and meltwater channels filled by upper Dogger Bank outwash sediments. The
impact of the second lobe was restricted to the western margin of Dogger Bank where it led to the
construction of a large (5-20km wide) thrust-complex (“western moraine”) composed of a thick
sequence (c. 100-150m thick) of glacitectonised sediments. The geometry of the structures within this
deep-seated moraine are consistent with ice-push driven by ice advancing from the west. The
boundary zone between the two moraine systems is structurally complex and overlain by an elongate
basin (up to 7-8km wide) filled by upper Dogger Bank sediments (10-40m thick) which were primarily
derived from the northeast. This sedimentary basin formed as the two ice lobes unstitched and
retreated from Dogger Bank. However the exact timing of the “decoupling” of the two ice masses
remains uncertain. Initial results indicate that the two ice masses were still in close proximity resulting
in the interleaving of the glacitectonised sediments within the moraines, with the unstitching of the
two ice lobes occurring during the early stages of the deglaciation of Dogger Bank.
The role of the Irish Sea Ice Stream in the palaeo-landscape evolution of the
Irish Sea, Celtic Sea and the shelf edge
Katrien Van Landeghem1, Edward Lockhart2, Richard Chiverrell1, James Scourse3, Daniel Praeg4, Claire
Mellett5, Margot Saher6, Louise Callard7, Sara Benetti8, Colm O'Cofaigh7, Chris Clark9
1
Bangor University; 2University of Liverpool; 3University of Exeter; 4Géoazur; 5Wessex Archaeology;
6
Bangor University; 7Durham University; 8Ulster University; 9University of Sheffield
The Irish Sea Ice Stream (ISIS) drained more than 17% of the British-Irish Ice Sheet at the Last Glacial
Maximum. Integrating surface and sub-surface geophysical, sedimentological and geotechnical
datasets allowed to better understand the dynamics behind ISIS ice margin retreat dynamics and how
this shaped the palaeo-landscapes in the Irish Sea and Celtic Sea. In all areas investigated, the
landscapes seems to have always been submerged during and after immediately after ice retreated.
It appears that the ISIS terminated at the shelf edge, and the rapid retreat is dated from micro-fauna
in the pro-glacial sequences. In the Irish Sea, the integrated analysis of a large dataset collected for
offshore wind farm development was contextualised by the palaeo-ISIS geochronology (27-20 ka BP).
It seems that during deglaciation, ISIS displayed on/off behaviour to ice streaming, with increasing
topographical influence and realignment of ice flows. In the mid- to outer- Celtic Sea, the largest
known linear sediment ridges contain glacigenic sediments. Sub-surface geophysical data analyses
allowed to tentatively unravel the interaction between a retreating ice margin, iceberg turbation and
strong tides with the existing Celtic Sea topography during early deglaciation. These megaridges could
represent glacifluvial features eroded during the post-glacial sea level rise. Alternatively, the partiallyeroded glacial topography in the Celtic Sea could have been mantled by post-glacial tidal deposits,
both subsequently eroded by a proposed mechanism of enhanced wave energy during decreasing
tidal energy in the later stages of sea level rise. The integration of available data across all megaridges
in the Celtic Sea would allow reconstruction of maximum ice margin extent across the Celtic shelf. It
might also shed light on the processes behind the sediment supply needed to build these megaridges,
whilst this exercise is relevant to build the increasingly important offshore sand inventories from our
(outer) continental shelf areas.
Geomorphological and seismostratigraphic evidence for multidirectional
polyphase glaciation of the northern Celtic Sea
Zsuzsanna Tóth1, Stephen McCarron2, Andrew Wheeler3, Stefan Wenau1, Stephen Davis4, Aaron Lim3,
Volkhard Spiess1
1
University of Bremen; 2Maynooth University; 3University College Cork; 4University College Dublin
A Quaternary stratigraphic succession preserved offshore Southeast Ireland (between Dungarvan to
Hook Head) records a sequence of depositional and erosional events that supports regional glacial
event models derived from nearby coastal sediment stratigraphies and landforms. Multichannel
seismic and Sparker data are presented and reveal a five-fold event stratigraphy. A regionally
widespread, largely acoustically massive facies (SU2)
interpreted as the ‘Irish Sea Till’ infills an uneven, channelized bedrock surface overlying irregular
mounds and discontinuous pockets of weakly stratified deposits (SU1) in bedrock lows that are likely
remnant, earlier Pleistocene diamicts and associated sediments. SU2 is truncated throughout the
study area by a strong, horizontal reflector and overlain by a thin, stratified acoustic facies (SU3),
suggestive of the development of a regional ice dammed palaeolake or smaller ponded water bodies
after the recession of ice. On the near shore bedrock platform to the north, a north to south oriented
linear narrow ridge at seabed is interpreted as an esker, and represents southward flowing subglacial
drainage associated with a restricted ice sheet advance onto the Celtic shelf postdating the SU1-SU3
seismostratigraphy. Onshore LIDaR data reveal drumlin orientations that corroborate the southerly
advance of ice into the Celtic Sea from the mainland. The evidence supports palaeoglaciological
models derived from nearby coastal localized sediment sequences comprising an LGM-aged crossshelf Irish Sea Ice Sheet flow from the east, followed by proglacial subaqueous deposition, and finally
an episode of offshore-directed Irish Ice Sheet ice flow at a regional scale. The offshore topography
marks a new limit for a restricted Late Midlandian Irish Ice Sheet advance from an inland ice dispersal
centre onto the Celtic Sea shelf offshore County Waterford.
The North Sea: a climatic and environmental archive
Natasha Barlow
University of Leeds
The North Sea is exceptional location for reconstructing Quaternary environmental change. It
provides known archives of sea level transgressions, was proximal to the ice sheets which were
present over Europe during preceding glacial periods and is in the intermediate-field of the current
Greenland ice sheet. Therefore it provides a unique opportunity to understand how the terrestrial,
coastal and marine landscape has evolved over time in response to regional and global forcings during
glacial-interglacial cycles.
In this presentation I will explore how sediments buried within the North Sea allow us to reconstruct,
with high precision, the nature of regional sea-level change and associate environmental change, both
during the Holocene and previous late Quaternary interglacials. Developing such records provides an
opportunity to be able to identify the source of ice melt which contributed to periods of sea-level rise
due to the position of the North Sea within the distinctive geometry, or ‘fingerprint’, of sea-level
change which occur with melting ice sheets. With a wealth of geophysical and sedimentary data
becoming available from industrial surveys in the region, this is an exciting time to do research into
the climatic and environmental changes in the North Sea.
Land–sea coupling of early Pleistocene glacial cycles in the southern North
Sea
Timme Donders1, Niels van Helmond1,2, Roel Verreussel3, Dirk Munsterman3, Johan ten Veen3, Robert
Speijer4, Johan Weijers1,5, Francesca Sangiorgi1, Francien Peterse1, Lucas Lourens1, Gert-Jan
Reichart1,6, Jaap Sinninghe Damsté1,6, Henk Brinkhuis1,6, Gesa Kuhlmann7
Utrecht University; 2Radboud University; 3TNO – Geological Survey of the Netherlands; 4KU Leuven;
5
Shell Global Solutions; 6Royal Netherlands Institute for Sea Research, 7German Federal Institute for
Geosciences and Natural Resources
1
The North Sea Basin (NSB) sediment archive provides an excellent opportunity to reconstruct Plio- and
Pleistocene climate. Due to the relatively isolated character of the basin and position on the hinge line
of terrestrial and marine environments, the NSB is a highly sensitive recorder of regional climate
change at the land-sea interface, and is key for improved definition of classic NW European terrestrial
stages. As part of this effort, we analysed early Pleistocene glacial-interglacial cycles in a cored marine
section located in the A/B blocks of the Dutch offshore sector. We assess disputed phase relations
between forcing and climatic response in the early Pleistocene that operated in the obliquity-driven
’40-kyr world’ with a multi-proxy paleoenvironmental record. Paleomagnetic and palynological data
provide a solid integrated timeframe that ties the obliquity cycles, expressed in the borehole
geophysical logs, to Marine Isotope Stages (MIS) 103 to 92, independently confirmed by a local benthic
oxygen isotope record.
Marine and terrestrial palynological and organic geochemical records provide high-resolution
reconstructions of relative terrestrial and sea surface temperature (TT and SST), vegetation, relative
sea level, and coastal influence. The record provides the first well-constrained stratigraphic sequence
of the classic terrestrial Praetiglian stage. Terrestrial signals were derived from the Eridanos
paleoriver, a major fluvial system that contributed a large amount of freshwater to the northeast
Atlantic. Analysis of the phase relations in the data reveal a dominantly Northern Hemisphere-driven
cooling that leads the glacial buildup and varies on the obliquity timescale. We aim to extend this
approach in suitable sections for both the Pliocene and early to middle Pleistocene.
Peat hunt: the 2017 and 2018 RV Pelagia early Holocene sea-level cruises on
the North Sea
Freek Busschers1, Marc Hijma2, Natasha Barlow3, Kim Cohen4, Rick Hennekam5, Bart Meijninger1,
Chris Mesdag2, Tine Missiaen6, Gert-Jan Reichart4,5, Jelte Stam1, Sytze van Heteren1
TNO – Geological Survey of the Netherlands; 2Deltares; 3University of Leeds; 4Utrecht University;
5
Royal Netherlands Institute for Sea Research; 6Flanders Marine Institute
1
During the early Holocene the ice sheets of North-America and Fennoscandia were rapidly melting
and sea level rose more than 30 m. In NW-Europe this transformed the vast plain of Rhine-ThamesDoggerland into the present North Sea and drove the people living there to higher grounds. But what
were the rates of sea-level rise over this period and what does this tell us about future rates of sealevel rise?
In order to answer these questions we carried out two research cruises with the RV Pelagia in 2017
and 2018 aiming to core the early Holocene transgressional contact, marked by a transition of
terrestrial (peat) to tidal deposits (clays and sands). The research area comprised the Brown Bank,
Oyster Ground and Dogger Bank and included (part of) the Dutch, German and British sectors.
Because the Early Holocene peat layer is laterally discontinuous, and the overlying substratum has a
variable thickness, a strict seismic survey and drilling campaign was designed in order to get the best
vertical depth coverage of the transgressional contact. Using the DINO database and GeoTOP based
modelling techniques, we first created a layer model of preserved early Holocene sediments and it
overburden thickness. On basis of this model we were able to plan the optimal cruise route for in-situ
high-resolution seismics and drilling. We then carried out Chirp and Sparker seismic surveys and
subsequently drilled the early Holocene sediments using a vibrocore. For the Brown Bank area we
used existing ultra-high-resolution seismic data for planning of the core locations.
We collected a unique set of 129 vibrocores that record the early Holocene transgressional contact
between -25 and -62m below MSL. Subsequently, the boreholes were macroscopically described,
photographed and sampled for radiocarbon dating and diatom, pollen and XRF analysis. Initial results
of these analyses are presented by Hijma et al.
SLIP hunt: first paleo sea-level data from the 2017 and 2018 RV Pelagia Early
Holocene sea-level cruises
Marc Hijma1, Freek Busschers2, Kim Cohen1,3, Natasha Barlow4, Paolo Stocchi5, Sytze van Heteren2,
Gert-Jan Reichart3,5, Wim Hoek3
Deltares; 2TNO – Geological Survey of the Netherlands; 3Utrecht University, 4University of Leeds;
5
Royal Netherlands Institute for Sea Research
1
The Netherlands has a long tradition of sea-level research from which vast amounts of data
accumulated over the last 60 years. These data, however, are scattered across large numbers of
papers and reports, were obtained using different sampling and dating techniques, have been in part
revised, and as a whole had not been uniformly scrutinized on quality and usability today. We present
new results for Greater Rotterdam (RMD) and the southern and central North Sea (Rhine-Thames
land, Doggerland) regions. The data from the latter region have been obtained in dedicated sea-level
research campaigns in 2017-2018 with research vessel the Pelagia and are still being analysed.
The RMD-part of the database now holds 50 sea-level index points (SLIPs) and 56 upper limiting data
points. The SLIPs cover an age-range of 8.8-3.0 ka, beginning at -21 m O.D. in the RMD near offshore.
For upper limiting data points, the coverage reaches further offshore tracing the Rhine palaeovalley,
back to 11 ka BP and down to -34 m O.D.
For the pre-9 ka BP period, for which data is to be sampled offshore, SLIPs are currently not available
from the Rhine palaeovalley. For the Brown Bank, Oyster Ground and Doggerbank region, only a few
SLIPs existed before our new research, but these includes considerable uncertainties with respect to
their sampled elevation, their indicative meaning and their age. The newly collected data come from
peat beds between -60 and -25 m O.D. and directly link the offshore region to the RMD. Our
presentation will include the preliminary results of the 2017-2018 research campaign, including XRFdata, diatom analysis, 14C-dates and sea-level index points.
Relative sea-level change in northwest Europe and the southern North Sea
during the Holocene: Determination of isostatic and (neo)tectonic subsidence
in the German Bight
Lutz Reinhardt1, Annemiek Vink1, Holger Steffen2, Manfred Frechen3
1
German Federal Institute for Geosciences and Natural Resources; 2Swedish Land Surveying Office;
3
Leibniz Institute for Applied Geophysics
A thorough understanding of the causes and effects of differential relative sea-level (RSL) rise in the
southern North Sea region since the end of the Last Glacial Maximum (LGM) is important to help
predict future morphological development along the intensively utilised northwest European coastal
zone. An observational database of Holocene RSL index points deriving mainly from dated basal peat
layers from Belgium, the Netherlands, and northwest Germany was plotted on a common time-depth
scale in Vink et al. (2007) and is expanded on here to include 20 more data points from the German
Bight (collected during the GPDN-project 2009-2013). RSL-rise varies in magnitude and form between
these regions, revealing a complex pattern of differential crustal movement attributed mainly to the
variable effects of isostatic and (neo)tectonic subsidence.
A non-linear, glacio- and/or hydro-isostatic subsidence component emerges, which is only small on
the Belgian coast but increases significantly to a value of >15 m since 10 cal. kyr BP in the German
Bight. This subsidence is at least in part related to the post-glacial collapse of the peripheral forebulge
that developed around the Fennoscandian centre of ice loading during the LGM, but may also be
associated with water and sediment loading of the North Sea Basin.
Empirical and modelling analysis of the new dataset of RSL index points from the German Bight shows
that (neo)tectonic subsidence has occurred in a direction approximately perpendicular to that of
glacio-isostatic subsidence during the last 10 cal. kyr. Tectonic subsidence increases from almost
negligible along the northwest German coast to ca. 0.5 m/kyr in the Dogger Bank area. Such estimates
of present-day offshore tectonic subsidence rates in the German Bight may be of interest for
companies dealing with commercial activities such as the installation of pipelines, offshore wind parks,
cable lines, etc.
Post-glacial vegetation history of the Dogger Bank, North Sea using plant
macrofossil analysis
Zicarlo van Aalderen1, Nathalie Van der Putten1, Tanya Lippmann1, Kees Kasse1, Marc Hijma2, Freek
Busschers3
VU University Amsterdam; 2Deltares; 3TNO – Geological Survey of the Netherlands
1
Until now understanding of regional post-glacial terrestrial vegetation in the North Sea region was
mainly established through pollen research. This means that local ecological conditions are
inadequately understood as pollen are a less suitable proxy for local vegetation reconstruction. Here,
light is shed on the local vegetation history using plant macrofossil analysis, through a qualitative and
quantitative analysis of an Early Holocene sediment core from the Dogger bank in the North Sea.
The results in this study use a subsampled core, taken from approximately 40 meters below sea level,
of 1 meter length, consisting mostly Pleistocene sand layers at the base, but including 30 centimeters
of Basal Peat. The peat is sharply overlain by marine clays related to Holocene transgression. A key
feature is that major changes in vegetation occur within 1 centimeter. In general, plant macrofossil
content in the peat deposits is dominated by bryophytes, both peat mosses and brown mosses. Peat
accumulation started with Sphagnum papillosum, quickly replaced by the brown moss Tomentypnum
nitens a centimeter above. Subsequently a mixture of brown mosses Warnstorfia spp. and
Drepanoclades spp. occur, finally followed by the re-occurrence of Sphagnum spp. Plant remains in
the layers dominated by Sphagnum spp. are well preserved, contrasting the remains in layers
dominated by brown mosses. Besides macrofossil analysis of the peat a loss on ignition analysis on
the entire core is included as well. High loss of mass values of the peat indicate organic matter.
The types of vegetation and their succession provide indications on factors such as ground water level,
acidity, salinity, as well as air temperature, but also sea level. For example, Tomentypnum nitens
prefers less acidic conditions compared to Sphagnum papillosum, so based on these results it is
possible to qualitatively reconstruct the local paleoecology and –environment, including its past
climate.
Towards integrated drowned landscape reconstructions of the North Sea
Wim Hoek1, Marjolein Gouw-Bouman1,2, Nelleke van Asch2, Kim Cohen1, Freek Busschers3, Marc
Hijma4
Utrecht University; 2ADC ArcheoProjecten; 3TNO – Geological Survey of the Netherlands; 4Deltares
1
Geomorphological and vegetation development since the end of the Weichselian is thoroughly
investigated and synthesised for the dry part of the Netherlands. The development of vegetation
during particularly the Lateglacial to Middle Holocene is very characteristic and related to both climate
changes and the geomorphological setting. Brook and river valleys or interfluvial highs consisting of
river terraces, coversands or ice-pushed ridges show specific vegetation patterns that developed in a
different way though time. Based on the geomorphological characteristics it is possible to reconstruct
vegetation cover patterns based on a dense network of palynologically investigated cores.
During 2017 and 2018 the peat beds in the North Sea were mapped using geophysics and several
shallow cores have been taken from buried peat layers at different depths for a.o. sea level
reconstructions. Dating of the base and top of the peat which developed often on a soil that formed
under dry local conditions represent water level rise and subsequent drowning of the former
landscape. The peat layers, however, also contain valuable information about the local and regional
environmental history before drowning, which can be used to reconstruct the former landscapes,
including the vegetation cover, for which little is known for this (drowned) part of the Lowlands.
Using an integrated approach to determine local conditions by e.g. lithological, sedimentological and
macrofossil analyses together with palynological analyses to determine regional vegetation conditions
it is possible to translate the coring locations to environmental landscape settings. With the
combination of other data such as the geophysics and geochemistry the detailed investigation of the
peat will provide a more comprehensive picture of the landscape before drowning.
The Elbe Paleovalley and its tributaries: Late glacial to postglacial drainage
system of the paleolandscape in today’s German Bight (North Sea)
Daniel Hepp1, Ayobami Abegunrin1, Hanno Keil1, Katrine Andresen2, Tobias Mörz1
MARUM – University of Bremen; 2Aarhus University
1
During the Last Glacial Maximum sea level lowstand, the Elbe Paleovalley was a large structure which
drained meltwaters along the southern margin of the Fennoscandian Ice Shield towards the North
Sea. This large structure was fed by various larger and smaller rivers indicated by both the paleovalleys
of the modern Weser, Ems, and Eider Rivers which drained the German low mountain range and a
channel network which drained the Dogger Bank. Our research project aims to understand the
development of the Elbe Paleovalley drainage system since the Last Glacial Maximum and its response
to the rapid Holocene sea level rise and focus on: (1) The pre-transgressional sediment deposits of the
Elbe Paleovalley, which where almost eroded, with exceptions of infill sediments from a channel
network at the valley plain, and some brackish deposits along the upper valley flanks; (2) The
Entenschnabel channel network, which drained the eastern Dogger Bank towards the Elbe
Paleovalley. The channel network was influenced by postglacial sea level rise and developed from a
single deep valley to a network of shallower rivers and tributaries. The morphology of this network is
comparable to river structures known from the western part of the Dogger Bank; (3) The Paleo-Ems,
which is the drowned extension of the modern Ems River discharged into the southern part of the
Elbe Paleovalley. Sedimentological and micropaleontological records of the valley infills revealed that
since 9,500 cal. yr. BP the depositional environment in the Paleo-Ems valley changed very rapidly,
within ~200 years, from freshwater to brackish water and finally to marine conditions. This prevent
the river from adjusting its gradient to the rapid rising sea-level. The infill sediments of the Elbe
Paleovalley and its tributaries provide new insights into the rapid and drastic changing early Holocene
coastal landscape in the German Bight.
Glacial isostatic adjustment and sea level of north-west Europe
Sarah Bradley1, Jeremy Ely1, Chris Clark1, Robin Edwards2, Ian Shennan3, Benoit Lecavalier4, Robert
Barnett5, Marc Hijma6
1
University of Sheffield; 2Trinity College Dublin; 3Durham University; 4Memorial University of
Newfoundland; 5University of Exeter; 6Deltares
The last British and Irish ice sheet (BIIS) was one of the smaller marine-based ice-sheets that grew
during the Last Glacial cycle, but it is by far the world’s best empirically constrained with the
completion of the BRITICE-CHRONO (B-C) project. One key outcome of the project was the
construction of a range of ice sheet advance and retreat histories for this region.
The pattern of relative sea level (RSL) and glacial-isostatic-adjustment (GIA) across this region is
spatially variable and highly non-monotonic. This is due to the temporally varying interplay between
the regional GIA signal, driven by the BIIS and Scandinavian ice sheet (SIS), and the global signal which
was driven by the deglaciation of the larger ice sheets. Extensive GIA modelling of this region has been
conducted. However, the new data from the B-C project has radically altered the input ice sheet
reconstructions required for the BIIS.
In this study, we develop a new ensemble of GIA models using a range of input reconstructions for (i)
the retreat history for the North Sea ice-sheet, although one outstanding challenge is constraining the
offshore ice histories due the limited number of older (> 12 ka BP) sea level data available, (ii) the
regional BIIS+SIS and (iii) the global ice sheets (including the North American ice sheet complex and
Antarctica). By comparing predictions of RSL with the ever-expanding database of SLIP ( > 2000 data
points) from across the British Isles and Netherlands we examine the interplay between the regional
and global ice sheets. We present new reconstructions for the regional paleogeography, ice sheets
and revised rates of ongoing GIA-driven sea-level rise across this region.
Late Glacial surface rupturing earthquakes in the Roer Valley Rift System
Ronald van Balen1,2, Kees Kasse1, Hessel Woolderink1, Marcel Bakker2
VU University Amsterdam, TNO – Geological Survey of the Netherlands
The Roer Valley Rift System (RVRS) is an active rift system situated in the southern part of the
Netherlands and adjoining areas in Belgium and Germany. The last extension phase started at the
Oligocene-Miocene transition and is still ongoing. Previous and ongoing research show that the
tectonic motions in the RVRS have affected the courses of branches of the Rhine-Meuse river system.
Results of new and previous trenching studies demonstrate that the bounding faults of the RVRS
experienced major surface rupturing earthquakes during the Late Glacial, contemporaneous with
glacio-isostatic forebulge collapse. In a new trench we were able to estimate the moment magnitude
to have been about 6.8 ± 0.3, based on a paleo-fault scarp height of ~1 m and a surface rupture length
of at least 32 km (by correlation to a previous trench). In general these results suggest that, although
the faulting is caused by rifting processes, it is the loading and unloading by ice-sheets which
determines when the faults have their most important displacements, and thus also have their most
important impacts on the rivers. These indirect effects of glacio-isostasy are in addition to the gradual
impacts of forebulge motions on the gradients and directions of the rivers.
The Roer Valley Rift system is part of the Lower Rhine Embayment, which in turn is part of the
European Cenozoic Rift System. The potential continuation of the active fault system in northwestern
direction, into the southern North Sea, is still a major question mark, because of lack of data and
studies.
New age and climate data from the Eemian sedimentary record in the
Amsterdam Saalian glacial basin
Kay Beets1, Johan W.H. Weijers2,3
1
VU University Amsterdam; 2Utrecht University; 3Shell Global Solutions
The sedimentary infill of the deep Saalian glacial Basins in the Netherlands contains intriguing and
detailed records of landscape and climate change over the late Saalian and the last Interglacial (Figure
1). New data on the carbonate oxygen isotope and MBT-CBT biomarker composition of the finely
laminated lacustrine deposits from Amsterdam Basin show a distinct covariation forced by the
dynamic temperature changes over the late Saalian-early Eemian stadial-interstadials.
Reconstructed mean annual temperatures increase rapidly from 6.5°C at the end of the Saalian to
13.5°C for the lacustrine first part of the Eemian, pollenzones E1-E3. A return to severly cold
conditions, of 5.5°C, occurs at the end of pollenzone E3 when the first marine influence starts to show
in this record (Figure 2). Enrichment of authigenic uranium by diffusion from the overlying (marine)
water into this early Eemian organic-rich marker-bed (“Harting layer”) sets its minimum age at
128.1±1.6 kyr based on mass-spectrometric 238U/232Th-230Th/232Th isochron dating.
Combined oxygen and strontium isotope composition of the abundant mollusc Corbula gibba together
with sediment MBT-CBT biomarker composition in the more than 30m-thick overlying Eemian
lagoonal deposits illustrate the close inter-relationship between regional sea level history,
temperature and precipitation-evaporation balance. Early warming to 26°C, after the initial very cold
phase, precedes regional sea level highstand, and occurs together with an increase in sedimentation
rate. Also, the repetitive finely laminated nature of the silty-clayey sediment generally persists
throughout, although some intervals have a more crumbly-homogeneous nature. Nevertheless, the
natural gamma-ray log of the Amsterdam Terminal drillcore shows a sedimentary cyclicity bundling at
~22 cycles over the ~34 meters of lagoonal Eemian deposits (Figure 3). Intriguingly, similar cyclic
gamma-ray logs are observed in other cores from Amsterdam Basin suggesting strongly episodic
external sediment fluxes into the Basin as function of landscape, climate and/or sea level variations.
Lithostratigraphy Amsterdam Terminal after Kruk, 1998 and Van Leeuwen et al., 2000.
MBT-CBT temperature reconstruction (orange) Lacustrine bulk carbonate d18O (black), mollusc
(black)/benthic foram (purple/blue) d18O, natural gamma-ray log data (red).
Natural gamma-ray log data over the lagoonal-marine Eemian sequence.
Tracing the Eemian: coastal response to Last Interglacial sea-level rise in the
southern North Sea
Victor Cartelle, Natasha Barlow
University of Leeds
During the Last interglacial (LIG) global mean sea level was likely 6-9 m higher than present, which
provides an ideal palaeo-laboratory to understand coastal response to sea-level rise. Buried LIG
sequences in the southern North Sea provide a valuable record of marine transgression and are being
unveiled in new geophysical and geotechnical datasets acquired as a consequence of offshore
renewable energy development. Integration of this data as part of a new European Research Council
project (RISeR), we aim to reconstruct the rate and nature of transgression during the LIG, from which
to produce models of estuarine and coastal response.
Preliminary analysis of sequences in two wind farm areas offshore the Netherlands (Hollandse Kust
noord (HKN) and zuid (HKZ), Fig.1) allow identification of several seismic units corresponding to
deposits from Holsteinian to Holocene age, recording contrasting preservation conditions in the two
areas. An Eemian flooding surface is preserved in HKZ, which is overlaid by thick deposits that include
extensive peats and channel fills (Fig.2A,B), bounded at the top by an irregular surface of Weichselian
age (Fig.2C). Mapping of the Eemian flooding surface reveals the drowning of an irregular landscape
with depths ranging from 58 to 37 m below modern sea level.
By comparison, Eemian deposits in HKN seem to be condensed, together with late Saalian and early
Weichselian sediments, as part of a single seismic unit (Fig.3A). Mapping of its lower bounding surface
shows distinctive incisions, north to south oriented (Fig.3B), interpreted as glacial features of Saalian
age, later filled by transgressive and regressive sediments. The upper limit of these deposits
corresponds to the pre-Holocene landscape, where a complex network of channels running east to
west has been mapped (Fig.3C). Further mapping of these deposits will allow us better understand
the flooding of the North Sea basin during the LIG.
Figure 1. Location of the Hollandse Kust noord (HKN) and zuid (KHZ) wind farm areas. Bathymetry
from EMODnet.
Figure 2. A) Seismic section showing the stratigraphy of seismic units identified in HKZ. B) Map of the
base of seismic unit HKZ3 in the north sector of HKZ, interpreted as an Eemian flooding surface. C)
Map of the base of seismic unit HKZ4 in the north sector of HKZ, displaying an irregular landscape of
Weichselian age. Geophysical datasets are from the Netherlands Enterprise Agency (available at
offshorewind.rvo.nl).
Figure 3. A) Seismic section showing the stratigraphy of seismic units identified in HKN. B) Map of the
base of seismic unit HKN2 in the north sector of HKN, interpreted as a Saalian erosive surface. C) Map
of the base of seismic unit HKN3 in the south sector of HKN, corresponding to the pre-Holocene
landscape. Geophysical datasets from the Netherlands Enterprise Agency (available at
offshorewind.rvo.nl).
Doggerland emerging: a survey of the archaeological potential of a vast
prehistoric landscape
Luc Amkreutz
National Museum of Antiquities and Leiden University
Apart from the geological developments in the North Sea Basin often going back to remote times, the
area also harbours an important archaeological record. From the earliest occupation of northwestern
Europe by early hominins to the final flooding of “Doggerland” some 8000 years ago finds and sites
indicate the presence of a vast prehistoric archive. For a long time this was more or less taken for
granted. There was an awareness that the geographical borders of Europe once ran differently from
today and that this area was inhabited, both during the Ice Ages and in the more recent Holocene.
However, attention for this lost landscape was limited as finds were sparse and far between and
investigating sites in the turbulent grey waters of the North Sea often thought too complicated. As a
result archaeological thinking often did not include this lost landscape and its inhabitants.
Over the past decades this perspective has changed. Against the background of increasing economic
activity archaeological attention also increased both off-shore and on shore. While the former benefits
from industrial seismic and augering data in combination with new technology, coring and sampling
campaigns, the latter benefits from a number of recent large infrastructural projects that yield
numerous finds and an enthusiastic amateur community. In this paper we will focus on these recent
developments with specific attention for the many finds from the Palaeolithic and Mesolithic periods
that have surfaced over recent years. Attention will be drawn to the new insights these finds have
delivered by combining a rich array of research techniques. The paper underlines the importance of
the North Sea area for understanding the early colonisation and occupation of Northwest Europe and
the interaction between people and landscape against often intensive and dynamic climate change.
Buried landscapes and the issue of seismic scale: A case study from Dogger
Bank, southern North Sea
Carol Cotterill1, Leo James2, Callum Duffy3, Kirsten Johnson1, Emrys Phillips1
1
British Geological Survey; 2RPS Energy Ltd; 3Logos Geoservices
Geology, Geophysics and Geotechnics can be viewed as the three pillars of a ground model.
Geotechnics tells a developer about the soil and rock properties and behaviour, Geology tells them
about the physical structure of the soils and the history of the processes that have affected them.
Geophysics is the window onto this hidden world, using acoustics to paint a picture of the sub-surface.
However, one size does not fit all in the world of geophysics, especially when dealing with geology
that is complex, or has undergone different processes across one specific project zone. One such
example is Dogger Bank in the southern North Sea Basin. In 2009, the Forewind Consortium (Equinor,
Statkraft, SSE Renewables and Innogy) won the right to take the Dogger Bank through to the planning
and consenting stage, and began a comprehensive site survey.
The regional seismic survey (Sparker) gave us glimpses of a glaciated, now buried landscape. The site
survey dataset, with seismic inlines at 100m spacing showed that the glaciated landsystem comprised
a number of moraine complexes, with a system of meltwater channels and topographic lows.
However, when moving to the final turbine layout stage, where interpretations needed to identify
variations in soil conditions within a 40m2 foundation zone, the previous surveys did not give the
project team the resolution required.
Therefore a third survey dataset was acquired. This ultra-high resolution 3D survey revealed
significantly more detail about various land-features, including the different generations of channel
infill, reverse thrusting within the moraine complexes and the lateral variability of sand lenses within
the foundation zone. All of these new insights further guide the geotechnical design basis, whilst
greatly enhancing our understanding of the evolution of this now buried glacial landscape.
The Significance of inferred Quaternary coastal and intertidal landscapes
Samuel Griffiths
CITiZAN, Museum of London Archaeology
The Gulf of Malo, with its associated Crown Dependencies of Jersey, Guernsey, Sark, Alderney and
associated smaller islands, which represent the high-points in a once low-lying plain, represents a
significant area of Quaternary submerged landscape. At the beginning of the penultimate glacial (MIS
6) this landscape can be described a fluctuating coastal plain with variable habitats (e.g. grassland, salt
marsh, intertidal flats) and numerous large mega-faunal species ideal for Neanderthal Middle
Palaeolithic hunting strategies, as evidenced at sites such as La Cotte de St Brelade (Callow and
Cornford 1986; Griffiths 2018), Grainfollet (Monnier 1986) and Nantois (Monnier 1986). Despite this
apparent rich resource, by contrast, these landscapes can be seen as relatively resource-poor based
on archaeological accumulations, palaeo-environment studies and landscape reconstructions
(Griffiths 2018 and refs. there-in).
This paper will argue the, often overlooked, importance of the past intertidal/coastal zone in the
Quaternary for resource encounter(s) and the implications for a greater understanding of the preLGM North Sea region over the past 500 kyr, specifically in regards to early Human behaviour and
resource access. Specifically using the Gulf of Malo/Celtic Shelf Edge as a proxy, resource encounter
models can be drawn to show the potential importance with the coastal/intertidal zone in the low
lying landscapes off the modern East Lincolnshire submerged offshore area and current intertidal
zone. This research is part of a new research direction for CITiZAN (the Coastal and Intertidal Zone
Archaeological Network) aiming to discuss past landscapes studied in the Humberside Discovery
Programme area over the next two years.
These surveys can then be compared with similar studies being undertaken by CITiZAN teams working
on submerged and semi-submerged landscapes on the coast in Essex, Kent, the Solent, Devon and
Liverpool Bay.
Targeting submerged Pleistocene landscapes off Happisburgh, UK
Rachel Bynoe1, Nick Ashton2, Simon Lewis3, Simon Parfitt4
1
University of Southampton; 2British Museum; 3Queen Mary University of London; 4Natural History
Museum London
The archaeological site of Happisburgh 3, Norfolk, sits on the western shore of the southern North
Sea, pushing back the date of occupation of northwest Europe to >0.8 million years ago. There have
been hints of submerged landscapes here for over 100 years, with the likes of Clement Reid publishing
on the search for these as early as 1890 and collectors referring to offshore oyster beds as the source
of Pleistocene fauna back into the 1820s. However, the search for these landscapes has been both
discontinuous and challenging. Recent efforts have begun to unravel this picture, with a large
collection of derived stone tools appearing to, in part, derive from submerged deposits. The analysis
of these, and associated fauna, has led to the discovery of a series of offshore exposures. With
palaeoenvironmental evidence pointing towards their formation at the edge of an estuarine zone, we
are beginning to piece together a series of early sites that have the potential to elucidate the use of
these near-coastal environments by early hominins. This is allowing us to begin thinking about how
and why these early hominins occupied these latitudes during such an early, and climatically
challenging, period.
The paper will discuss ongoing research into these submerged landscapes, specifically the methods
used for their location and investigation, offshore finds and analysis, and future directions.
Revealing the lost landscapes of Cardigan Bay, Wales: mapping the Holocene
transgression using parametric echosounder data
Rachel Harding1, Richard Bates2, Martin Bates3, Vincent Gaffney1
1
University of Bradford; 2University of St. Andrews; 3University of Wales Trinity Saint David
Mythology has hinted at a lost landscape west of Wales in such legends as Cantre Gwaelod, fuelled by
the 5,000-year-old submerged forests at Ynyslas and Borth and sightings of human habitation offshore
between the rivers Ystwyth and Teifi. The ERC-funded Lost Frontiers Project has surveyed a buried
palaeo-valley of late Glacial–Holocene age below ‘Trawling Ground’, a NE–SW-trending depression,
3–8 km offshore. The new high-resolution parametric echosounder data is the first to be acquired to
understand the archaeological palaeo-landscape in decades.
Initial mapping has revealed a NE–SW-trending dendritic valley with a maximum width of 2.6 km and
a maximum depth of 20 m. South of Aberaeron, the channel swings E–W towards St. George’s
Channel. The seismic character has been correlated to borehole data from the 1970s and has
identified an estuarine–shallow marine sedimentary succession younger than 8740+/-110 years BP.
The geomorphology follows the onshore drainage pattern, and the offshore continuation of presentday rivers (Rheidol, Ystwyth, and Aeron) fed into the trunk valley from present-day West Wales. The
aggradational estuarine succession infilling the valley from the west suggests a high sediment supply
slowing the rate of transgression from rising early Holocene sea level.
The potential for archaeological prospecting is focused on a network of channels entering the valley
from the now-drowned West, which is yet to be fully imaged by seismic survey and may have been
inhabited during the Mesolithic. The mapping has also identified a ‘pinch point’ in the valley, where
the antecedent geology results in a shallowing and narrowing. This could have acted as a crossing
place for animals and humans and could be an area important for fishing. Further seismic acquisition
and new borehole data are required to fully assess the archaeological potential of the area.
High Tide – Low Tide. Bruges’ late-medieval harbor system as a maritime
cultural landscape - an interdisciplinary research project
Frieda Bogemans1, Vanessa Heyvaert1,2, Dante De Ruijsscher2, Jan Dumolyn2, Stephen Louwye2,
Maxime Poulain2, Jan Trachet2, Wim De Clercq2
RBINS – Geological Survey of Belgium; 2Ghent University
1
Medieval Bruges and its port system, composed of an interconnected structure of outports along the
Zwin waterway, forms a classic historical example of a hub in an international trading system that
connected the North Sea area with the Baltic and Mediterranean regions.
For more than a century, researchers approached the medieval heyday of Bruges essentially by means
of archival/historical studies and soil studies. Since the 1980’s archaeological research was also carried
out, but the integration of historical and archaeological data was non-existent. Only recently,
landscape-archaeological data (implying archaeological, geophysical, remotely sensed and
cartographic data) and historical data were combined leading to a spatio-temporal and functional
reconstruction of the lost harbor-towns of Hoeke and Monnikerede (Trachet 2016).
To obtain an overall picture of the medieval evolution of the maritime cultural landscape near Bruges
an interdisciplinary project is started, incorporating geological, archaeological and historical data.
Research questions such as ‘How the medieval Zwin waterway came into being, how the port system
interacted with the environment, how the connectivity within the port system operated and what was
the spatial-temporal evolution of the infrastructural and functional organization of the harbour
settlements along the Zwin waterway’ will be tackled for the first time. Hereby the landscape
evolution is seen as the link between the different disciplines.
Essential to achieve this goal is to start in a time slice before the development of the late medieval
Zwin waterway because the nature of the subsurface may affect the impact and strength of the
triggering factor(s). The reconstruction of the sedimentary environments (based on drillings -new and
existing-, excavations, video CPT’s) will provide information concerning the driving mechanisms
behind the paleogeographic evolution and their possible complex relationship.
Out of Doggerland ? Early Holocene climate change and the Mesolithic
‘Rhine-Meuse-Scheldt culture’
Hans Vandendriessche, Philippe Crombé
Ghent University
Mesolithic hunter-gatherers in the North Sea basin faced multiple climatic and environmental changes
during the Early Holocene. Overall climatic amelioration led to eustatic sea-level rise and gradual
reforestation, while abrupt cooling events (e.g. 9.3 and 8.3 ka calBP events) caused short-time
decreases in ground water level/fluvial activity and increases in wildfires. The most dramatic
environmental change, however, must have been the inundation of the North Sea basin, responsible
for a loss of more than 100,000km² of habitable land between ca. 11 000 and 8000 cal BP. During the
Middle Mesolithic (ca. 9 400 – 8 200 cal BP), the Rhine-Meuse-Scheldt area, as opposed to the
neighbouring regions, sees the development of an innovative type of projectile point (i.e. microlith
with invasive retouch) and an increased use of Wommersom quartzite. These new projectile points
however do not seem to hold any functional advantages over the previously used geometric and
simple backed points. Instead, based on ethnographic parallels, we argue that this new arrowhead
style was adopted to visualize group affiliation as a response to increasing competition for resources,
territoriality and demographic pressures, triggered by the movement of people from the inundated
Doggerland areas towards the southern fringes of the North Sea basin.
References
Ph. Crombé, 2019. Mesolithic projectile variability along the southern North Sea basin (NW Europe):
Hunter-gatherer responses to repeated climate change at the beginning of the Holocene. PLoS ONE
14(7): e0219094. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0219094
Last Glacial river valleys of the Southern North Sea Basin: continuous-cover
context for spotty-cover finds and sites
Kim Cohen
Utrecht University
Bones, peats, axes, antlers, tree trunks, skulls, molars and stories: when dredged up from the North
Sea from drowned landscapes they are sure to come from either valleys (big and small) or interfluve
areas neighboring these. The understanding of the valley networks that existed at various stages
through the last glacial is quite developed, onshore buried by coastal plain deposits as well as offshore.
Keeping palaeogeographical overview of the knowledge has turned out quite useful both for
attributing landscape context to spot finds and analysing distributions and densities (in archaeology
and paleontology), as well as in prospecting niche sites for targeted paleoenvironmental sampling
(vegetation history, sea-level history, palaeoclimatology). Vice-versa, new finds and new surveying
demand to update the understanding: improving the spatial and chronological resolution, replacing
extrapolations with observational evidence in the mapping of valleys, notably using interpreted
seismics (that are increasingly available lately). The presentation will show map-series of the valley
network development drawing illustrations of how the mapping has been used in the publications
below:
Hijma et al. (2012) Pleistocene Rhine-Thames landscapes: geological background for hominin
occupation of the southern North Sea region. Journal of Quaternary Science 27.
Cohen et al. (2014) North Sea palaeogeographical reconstructions for the last 1 Ma. Netherlands
Journal of Geosciences 93.
Cohen et al. (2017) The North Sea. In Flemming et al. (Eds.), Submerged Landscapes of the European
Continental Shelf Volume 1 Quaternary Paleoenvironments.
Hijma & Cohen (2019). Holocene sea-level database for the Rhine-Meuse Delta, The Netherlands.
Quaternary Science Reviews 214
Peeters et al. (2019) Preservation of Last Interglacial and Holocene transgressive systems tracts in the
Netherlands. Earth-Science Reviews 188.
Niekus et al. (2019) Middle Paleolithic complex technology and a Neandertal tar-backed tool from the
Dutch North Sea. PNAS.
Multiscale onshore-offshore valley network off the Rhine-Meuse delta (Rhine, Meuse, Scheldt, local
drainage) - from Hijma & Cohen (2019), with key sites for Holocene sea-level reconstruction.
'Peopling Doggerland': submerged stone age finds from the Dutch North Sea
Bjørn Smit1, Marcel Niekus2, Luc Amkreutz3, Dimitri Schiltmans4
1
Cultural Heritage Agency of the Netherlands; 2Foundation for Stone Age Research in the
Netherlands; 3National Museum of Antiquities and Leiden University; 4City of Rotterdam
Archaeological Service
For several decades the Southern North Sea is known as a treasure trove of sediments, bones and
artefacts dating from the Pleistocene and early Holocene. The area is crucial for our understanding of
colonisation and occupation behaviour at these latitudes. The finds derive from former landscapes
that have been, mostly gradually, inundated following the last glaciation. These bones and artefacts
were fished or dredged from the North Sea bed or are transported to the beaches in sand which is
used for coastal reinforcement and reclamation as part of the continuing struggle of the Netherlands
to keep their country dry. The research of the artefact in combination with information on the
formation and development of the landscape and environment is paramount in the understanding of
prehistoric human-landscape dynamics.
Mesolithic core axe found on the beach near The Hague (photo Donny Crispijn).
Mesolithic antler axe found on the beach of Texel.
The Scheur – a unique prehistoric fossil graveyard off the Belgian coast
Tine Missiaen1, Maikel De Clercq2,3, Pascal Hablutzel1, Bram Langeveld4, Olivier Lambert5, Mietje
Germonpré5
1
Flemish Marine Institute; 2Ghent University; 3Jan De Nul; 4Natural History Museum Rotterdam;
5
RBINS – OD Earth and History of Life
Over the past decades fishermen have dredged up large amounts of unique prehistoric
palaeontological material at the Scheur, a navigation channel near Zeebrugge (Belgium). Especially the
large number of walrus bones from the Last Glacial (116,000-12,000 years ago) is striking. The bone
material indicates that a large colony must have lived here, possibly the most southern walrus colony
in the world. Two targeted surveys in 2017 and 2018 produced additional finds of Late Pleistocene
land mammals, related to interglacial fauna (wild horse, aurochs, red deer, roe deer, rhinoceros, boar
and hippo) as well as glacial fauna (brown bear; wild horse; red deer).
All the bone material is most likely preserved in situ, derived from layers exposed at the seafloor. Due
to maintenance dredging of the navigation channel 10 to 12 m of sediments was removed, thereby
exposing older Late Pleistocene and even Paleogene strata. Determination and dating of the fossils
are currently ongoing, including the screening for ancient DNA. Radiocarbon analysis of the walrus
bone is ambiguous (the method only goes up to 40,000 years).
Palaeogeographic reconstructions based on seismic and core data suggest the presence of an incised
valley underneath Zeebrugge. During the last interglacial this fluvial landscape gradually transformed
into an estuary protected by large (intertidal) islands composed of Paleogene strata. After the
interglacial highstand climate deteriorated and sea levels started to fluctuate several tens of meters.
This caused the recurrent emerging and submerging of the former islands on which walrus were now
able to live. When sea levels continued to fall during the coldest stages of the Early Glacial, the
landscape transformed once more into a fluvial landscape. The near-coastal position of the study area
finally resulted in a complicated geological architecture rich in fossil from both glacial and interglacial
periods.
Using citizen science to study fossil vertebrates from the North Sea
Bram Langeveld1, Bas van Geel2, Dick Mol1
1
Natural History Museum Rotterdam; 2University of Amsterdam
The Dutch government dredges millions of cubic meters of sediment from the North Sea annually to
nourish its beaches and to build large coastal infrastructures such as the extension to the port of
Rotterdam (Maasvlakte 2). The dredged sediments are usually sandy and Pleistocene or Early
Holocene in age and especially in the southern half of the country they are fossiliferous. This has not
gone unnoticed with private fossil collectors and over the decades a significant and dedicated
community of citizen scientists has emerged that collects and documents the dredged fossils (and
artefacts) and saves them from weathering and erosion, ultimately making them available for scientific
study and in many cases eventually depositing them in museum collections. Many of these collectors
are united in the Werkgroep Pleistocene Zoogdieren (Working Group on Pleistocene Mammals) which
together with social media enables very efficient sharing of finds, identifications and information. We
demonstrate the power of citizen science in studying the drowned Pleistocene and Holocene
vertebrate faunas of the North Sea using three examples: 1) abundant new material of the great auk,
significantly adding to its rare North Sea fossil record, 2) paleo-environmental data from molar
embedded vegetation remains, revealing herbivore diet composition and 3) abundant coprolites of
cave hyenas, potentially acting as a rich source of paleo-ecological data. We quantify search effort by
the citizen scientist fossil collectors and demonstrate that they indeed provide an invaluable
contribution to saving and studying our paleontological heritage.
The North Sea Prehistory Research and Management Agenda 2019
Hans Peeters1, Luc Amkreutz2, Kim Cohen3, Marc Hijma4
1
University of Groningen; 2National Museum of Antiquities and Leiden University; 3Utrecht University;
4
Deltares
It is general knowledge that the southern North Sea harbours a vast array of submerged prehistoric
archaeological and environmental remains. In 2009, the North Sea Prehistory Research and
Management Framework (NSPRMF) set out a broad set of research and management themes, topics
and priorities which were deemed relevant regarding the prehistoric cultural heritage of the southern
North Sea. Now, in 2019, we address the question: Where do we stand after a decade of work? In the
past ten years, a lot of work has been done and progress has been made; however, we are still far
from meeting all of the priorities defined. While the themes and topics of the NSPRMF 2009 remain
relevant today, based on the experiences over the years, they have been revised and updated for this
NSPRMF2019.
The geo-archaeological potential of the eastern North Sea – initial
considerations based on existing geophysical data
Katrine Andresen1, Daniel Hepp2, Tobias Mörz2, Hanno Keil3, Volkhard Spiess3, Peter Moe Astrup4
Aarhus University; 2MARUM – University of Bremen; 3University of Bremen; 4Moesgaard Museum
1
The ancient but now drowned and buried Doggerland in the North Sea formed from the complex
interplay of glacial and sea level forcing on erosion and deposition after the Last Glacial Maximum
(LGM). During this interplay, the North Sea region experienced several rearrangements, evolving from
a partly ice-covered tundra, through fluvial drainage and estuarine deposition, to a marine
intracontinental basin. Drowning of the Doggerland took place approximately 11-9 ka with the Dogger
Bank and the eastern North Sea being submerged the latest, according to existing paleo-sea-level
models. Archaeological artefacts have been recovered from the southern North Sea, indicating that
prehistoric humans occupied at least parts of the Doggerland.
In the western and southern North Sea, larger mapping campaigns based on geophysical data from
the offshore industry have led to a good understanding of the paleolandscape evolution in these areas
and in turn on the geological constraints set for the early human settlements. On the contrary, the
eastern North Sea and its geo-archaeological potential remains poorly investigated since no similar
coherent mapping studies have been undertaken in the Danish and German North Sea.
Using existing geophysical data, sea-level models and the developed methodology for submerged
landscape mapping, this project aims to produce a coherent mapping of the paleolandscapes in the
eastern North Sea after the LGM. The objective is to test the geo-archaeological potential of this area
of Doggerland. Compared to the inner Danish waters, where a wealth of findings document the
inhabitation of prehistoric humans, no particular archaeological findings have been discovered in the
eastern North Sea so far. Understanding the reasons for this, whether it be related to past and present
geological processes of erosion, deposition or bypass (landscape preservation parameters) or early
human migration patterns constitute elements in the process of investigating the geo-archaeological
potential.
Transnational seabed mapping and subsurface modeling
Vera Van Lancker
RBINS – OD Nature and Ghent University
1
Transnational mapping and subsurface modelling are by no means simple endeavours. Often, they
start through groups or individuals willing to cooperate and add value to national datasets. More and
more, producing transnational data products is becoming a goal on its own. This evolution is
stimulated and facilitated by datasets that are increasingly free of charge and available in formats that
are easily accessible and mergeable, as well as by technical advancement. Shifting mindsets, common
regional to global socio-economic and environmental challenges, but of course also funding
opportunities (e.g., EMODnet) have paved the way.
However, significant optimisation is still needed on the data level. Nowadays, new data are mostly
acquired using ‘sound’ protocols and calibration procedures, and data descriptions and
interpretations benefit from common vocabularies. However, legacy datasets compiled from national,
regional and local archives cannot be used immediately; they require many standardisation and
harmonisation steps. Quality assessments, although a must, are only seldomly quantified and taken
along in the mapping or modelling process. As of yet, few standardised procedures are in place to
obtain products with estimated model ánd data accuracy at various spatial scales.
To a typical end user, products from 3D (sub)surface modelling look more convincing than traditional
paper maps, but they too are only as good as the underlying data. As with mapping, many complex
techniques exist increasing the predictive power. Statistics now drive the delineation of seabed classes
or facies, though geological expert knowledge and common sense are needed more than ever to guide
the process. Speed and flexibility in visualisation are key, with mismatches emerging rapidly, different
parameter settings demonstrating their advantages and disadvantages, but also unveiling knowledge
gaps. Improving methodologies for querying data and data products enable the effective control of
tailor-made model output. Data portals, and ideally decision support systems, are becoming
increasingly powerful and therefore more relevant for applications. With web services, users can easily
incorporate new products into their own geographic information systems, facilitating exploration and
quantification of relationships between a wide range of multidisciplinary datasets.
In this keynote, examples will be given of broad- to small-scale applications related to the mapping
and modelling of seabed sediments, geomorphology, and subsurface geology. For all, tiered
approaches are needed, including the necessary quality control. Mapping goals should be defined
upfront, since ‘one size fits all’ seldomly delivers the best product. Importantly, underlying databases
should be designed to have as much flexibility as possible. They should include the full spectrum of
available data, original and standardised, and with quality parametrised, enabling fully customized
products serving the purpose. Collaborative actions, shared data acquisition platforms, adequate
technology, and aligned visions are more than ever desired.
Danish North Sea marine geological data as input for transnational largescale projects
Niels Nørgaard-Pedersen, Matthew Owen, Jørn Bo Jensen, Jørgen O. Leth, Ole Bennike
Geological Survey of Denmark and Greenland
The Geological Survey of Denmark and Greenland (GEUS) performs national mapping of the seabed
and subsurface modelling for raw material exploration, windfarm foundations and archaeological
screening, cable alignments as well as habitat mapping. Through this work, we have an extensive
database (MARTA) of marine geophysical data and geological samples. Our knowledge of the record
of glacial and interglacial sediments and past landscapes in the Danish North Sea is most extensive in
the more shallow water parts where we have the highest data coverage . The northern part of the
Danish North Sea is characterised by Late Weichselian ice sheet terminal moraine deposits,
superimposed by relatively thick, late glacial glacio-marine deposits and various Holocene dynamic
sandy units. South of the ice sheet limit, Weichselian meltwater deposits are extensively present,
superimposing the older Saalian glacial landscape, and in some regions Eemian marine deposits. A
network of buried glacial valleys known from most parts of the North Sea have repeatedly influenced
drainage patterns and the progressive marine transgressions in the area. In addition, areas
characterised by intense glaciotectonic deformation reveal former glaciodynamic patterns.
Future work must emphasize transnational cooperation and networking for a number of reasons. First,
in order to unravel the Middle-Pleistocene to Late-Holocene geological record and refine our
understanding of the causes and effects of environmental changes. Second, the need of harmonization
because the geological classifications and interpretation often changes at national boundaries due to
age of interpretation and different backgrounds of the geologist. This causes significant challenges for
future transnational construction projects, where the geological classification changes due to
administrative boundaries. Thus, in order to facilitate future large-scale projects, such as
interconnector cables and the ‘North Sea Hub’ there is an urgent requirement to harmonise the
stratigraphic interpretation around the North Sea.
High-resolution investigations of the shallow subsurface in the Dutch Sector
of the North Sea for aiding the development of wind farm zones
Menno Hofstra, Bogusia B. Klosowska, Emilia D. Piasecka, Daniël Brouwer, Marijn van Cappelle, Joek
Peuchen
Fugro Netherlands
Mapping of the shallow subsurface of the North Sea was initiated in the last century, primarily relying
on sparsely distributed sampling data and geophysical data intended for the deeper geology. In recent
years, the Dutch Sector of the North Sea is seeing substantial investments in large-scale wind farms as
part of the global energy transition. In order to reduce both environmental impact and risks associated
with construction, large amounts of geodata for the shallow subsurface (< 100 m below seafloor below
seafloor) are acquired. These datasets are unique as they cover vast areas (each in the order of 200
km2 to 1000 km2) and include integrated closely-spaced seismic reflection data, geotechnical data
(CPT and sampling) and age-dating information. Furthermore, due to recent advancements in multitip sparker sources, the combination of ultra-high resolution multichannel and shallow profiler system
data is specifically suited to allow detailed investigation of the shallow subsurface.
An overview is presented of the geophysical and geotechnical site investigation data as well as the
integrated geological ground models, which focus on tying in with existing knowledge of the shallow
subsurface. It is shown that the integrated geodata for wind farm development can be a significant
contribution to a more detailed understanding of the Late Quaternary record. The added value is
predominantly the major increase in data density as well as the novel shallow-subsurface resolution
of the seismic reflection data. The results highlight the potential to improve the geological framework
with these new and publicly available datasets for the offshore shallow subsurface of the Netherlands.
Planned wind farm development within the Dutch Sector of the North Sea (RVO) displayed on the
geological map of The Netherlands (Geologische Dienst Nederland, TNO).
Geomorphological mapping of the Belgian seabed and its submerged
landscapes
Lars Kint1, Maikel De Clercq2,3, Vera Van Lancker1,2
RBINS – OD Nature; 2Ghent University; 3Jan De Nul
1
Low- and high-resolution Digital Terrain Models (DTMs) are available as interoperable gridded data
layers and data products. These bathymetry data, together with increasing availability of various
terrain analysis tools, give new impetus to a more uniform geomorphological mapping of the marine
realm. To test approaches in sandy shelf areas, a multi-scale analysis was already performed on
bathymetric data from the Belgian part of the North Sea using the Benthic Terrain Modeler (BTM) in
ArcGIS and other GIS-related raster tools for analysing the topography of the seabed.
Geomorphological features present on the Belgian Continental Shelf are sandbanks and crests, valleys
and depressions, and sandwave fields. Recently, a derivative of the digital bathymetry model was
constructed based on in-depth processing and re-interpretations of sediment cores in conjunction
with extensive seismic records, resulting in a depth-converted structure map (DCSM) of the TopPaleogene surface at high-resolution scale of 1:250 000 (De Clercq et al., 2016). Similar GIS analyses
have now been conducted on the appearing submerged landscapes from 120,000 to 100,000 years
ago allowing revealing planation surfaces, escarpments, slope breaks, paleo-valleys and -ridges in an
automated way. Both resulting geomorphological mapping products contribute to EMODnetGeology’s work packages on geomorphology and submerged landscapes.
De Clercq, M., Chademenos, V., Van Lancker, V., & Missiaen, T. (2016). A high-resolution DEM for the
Top-Palaeogene surface of the Belgian Continental Shelf. Journal of Maps 12(5), 1047-1054.
A very high resolution geomorphological and habitat mapping investigation
of the Northern Paleovalley, English Channel (La Manche)
Riccardo Arosio, Jon Hawes, John Sperry
Cefas
The causes for Late Quaternary separation of Britain from continental Europe are a debated issue.
Researchers have suggested that the opening of the Dover strait was caused by a catastrophic spillover
of a proglacial lake ~450 ka ago. The spillover is thought to have caused a megaflood event into the
subaerial English Channel that produced a drainage system and erosional features, amongst which the
Northern paleovalley [1], [2] is a prominent example. An alternative theory suggests that the
breaching and erosion of the region was incremental, as opposed to catastrophic.
As part of the ongoing monitoring efforts of Offshore Overfalls Marine Conservation Zone (MCZ), the
R.V. Cefas Endeavour collected high resolution multibeam bathymetric (1 m) and backscatter (0.5m)
datasets over an area coincident with the Northern Paleovalley (Figure 1). These were ground-truthed
against 32 sampling stations, where high definition videography data and Hamon grab sediment
samples were acquired. Taking advantage of these new datasets, we aim to investigate the
sedimentary and geomorphological features of the Northern Paleovalley in the greatest detail to date,
determining the presence or absence of meso and micro geomorphological “forms”. These forms may
then be correlated to the macroscale studies which have been carried out in the past, helping to
further unravel the history of the English Channel [1].
Following on from the detection of microscale and mesoscale forms, we will undertake
topographically driven habitat mapping of the paleovalley, further informed by substrate classification
derived from backscatter intesnity. These maps will be created using object-based image analysis of
both the bathymetry and backscatter datasets, in conjunction with ground-truthed habitat data and
predictive modelling using supervised learning algorithms. We will then use these maps to ascertain
the relationship between those epifaunal communities observed, and the broad-scale geomorphology
present across the paleovalley system.
Plate A shows a 3D presentation of portion of the data collected, with Plate B presenting an overview
of the whole MBES data collection area (CEND0119 cruise). The blue area in plate A illustrates the
central glacio-fluvial drainage channel [1], and the orange-red area to the right is a partial
presentation of ‘teardrop’ island structure. The linear feature running through the image is the
Wight-Bray fault [4], trending West to East through the study area.
Hierarchies in geomorphological seabed mapping for multi-purpose end use
Sytze van Heteren1, Marcel Bakker1, Freek Busschers1, Jelte Stam1, Vera Van Lancker2
TNO – Geological Survey of the Netherlands; 2RBINS – OD Nature and Ghent University
1
The pan-European digital terrain model (DTM) of European seas, provided on the EMODnet
Bathymetry portal, has triggered a wave of geomorphological seabed mapping in which bathymetric
features are interpreted in terms of origin and evolution. The latest version of the DTM, published in
2018, has a spatial resolution of roughly 100x100 m. Source data vary in type (single- versus
multibeam) and density. For selected areas, separate high-resolution DTMs are available on the portal
at 60x60 to 4x4 m resolution. The different resolutions enable mapping of geomorphology at varying
scales. Whereas the relationship between data density and map scale is straightforward for
bathymetry, with depth as its main indicator and visualized resolution a function of zoom level, it is
more intuitive for geomorphology. In principle, bedforms as small as megaripples and tidal creeks are
mappable but they need to be deleted or simplified when zooming out. Equally importantly, however,
the number of feature classes shown onscreen or in print is best limited to a set maximum to ensure
map legibility. Classification according to a consistent hierarchy enables the end user of online
geomorphological seabed maps to render a scale and granularity that is fit for purpose. Main
formative process (such as glacial, open-marine and coastal) is most suitable for a pan-European view
and analysis. Increasingly specific subclasses at lower levels can be depicted when zooming in on
transnational, regional or local issues.
Mapping program of the coastal plain of the Netherlands
Peter Vos, Sieb de Vries, Renée de Bruijn, Kay Koster
TNO – Geological Survey of the Netherlands
We present the southwestern part of the new geological map of the coastal plain of the Netherlands.
This map is presently being developed by the Geological Survey of the Netherlands (TNO-GSN).
Previous maps covering just parts of this area were produced by TNO-GSN predecessors between the
1950-80s. Since then, new borehole data, changes in scientific insights, incomplete spatial coverage
of previous maps, and the present-day focus on digital information systems, demanded this earlier
work to be updated.
Prime mapping input data encompasses several hundreds of thousands of boreholes, added with cone
penetration tests (CPT) in areas of relative borehole data scarcity. These borehole and CPT data are
stored in a national subsurface database managed by TNO-GSN, which we semi-automatically query
to obtain insights in geological build-up. Geomorphological features are mapped with use of a
nationwide high-resolution DEM. Combined, this extensive dataset allows for a map with a scale
1:10,000.
The mapping project delivers two types of maps: (i) a geological map of the upper 5 meter of coastal
plain stratigraphy with an overlay of relevant topographic features such as embankments, urban
areas, and residual channels, and (ii) a geomorphological map of Pleistocene deposits underlying the
coastal plain. Combined, these maps provide valuable insight in the local to regional scale
development of the Holocene coastal plain of the Netherlands.
The new mapping of the coastal plain also aid in TNO-GSN’s 3D geological model developments,
paleogeographic reconstructions, and provide context for archaeological research. Furthermore, the
newly mapped marine deposits can be correlated to coastal deposits offshore that drowned during
Holocene relative sea-level rise.
Lost Frontiers: Mapping and prospecting submerged Holocene landscapes
Simon Fitch1, Vince Gaffney1, Richard Bates2, Rachel Harding1, Andrew Fraser1
1
University of Bradford; 2University of St. Andrews
The ERC funded Lost Frontiers Project is a unique interdisciplinary archaeological project using legacy
seismic combined with newly acquired cm-scale resolution sub-bottom and vibrocore data, to reveal
Holocene submerged landscapes in unprecedented detail on a regional scale. The project has focused
on the European submerged landscapes of the southern North Sea (Doggerland) and Irish Sea. Seismic
mapping along with ground truthing from borehole allows the project to evaluate the potential for
the recovery of both environmental, SedaDNA and archaeological material.
The project has focused on several key palaeovalleys with the study area, which are beginning to
reveal the story of the inundation of these once inhabited lands due to early Holocene sea level rise.
Cores within these areas show sequences of terrestrial deposits to tidally-influenced laminated silts
and muds to fully marine sediments. These sequences are tied to the seismic character and
extrapolated away from the boreholes. This record of the early Holocene inundation not only has
implications for our knowledge of the Mesolithic landscape but also is revealing insights into the nonuniform inundation of landscapes, which has occurred numerous times in the past 500 kyrs.
Geo-archaeological mapping of the Zeebrugge area, Belgium
Maikel De Clercq1,2, Vasilis Chademenos1, Tine Missiaen3
1
Ghent University; 2Jan De Nul; 3Flanders Marine Institute
A pilot study was recently performed focusing on the accessibility of the harbour of Zeebrugge. Old
studies suggest the presence of a buried palaeovalley and sandstone layers, which may cause stability
and/or structural problems. At the same time, the large amount of fossil bones found offshore
Zeebrugge indicates an archaeological ‘hotspot’. The aim of the pilot study was to obtain a detailed
model of the subsurface and map the palaeolandscape evolution of the area.
A dense network of high frequency acoustic subbottom data was obtained in 2016–2017. Due shallow
gas this only provided limited information. In 2018 a series of deep CPTs and cores was performed.
Continuous cores were photographed and described in detail, and sampled for environmental
analyses (pollen, diatoms, shells, C14, OSL). Discontinuous cores were sampled every 0.5-1 m for
lithological and geotechnical analysis. Integration with existing (not seldom old) data (both offshore
and onshore) resulted in a 3D layer model of the Zeebrugge area as well as a highly detailed 3D voxel
model (voxel size 50x50x0.5m).
Palaeogeographic reconstruction suggest that the palaeovalley underneath the harbour formed
during the Saalian due to glacio-isostatic forebulge updoming and river deflection. The following
Eemian sea-level rise combined with forebulge relaxation resulted in gradual transformation into an
estuarine coastal landscape dominated by large islands composed of various Paleogene strata. During
the Eemian highstand the complete area was submerged until sea levels started to drop in the
Weichselian Early Glacial and the islands emerged again. As sea levels continued to fall the rivers
retained their former position. During the more temperate episodes of the Weichselian, precipitation
and permafrost melting created a peaty overbank environment. At the onset of the Holocene the area
inundated and transformed into a back-barrier environment controlled by a balance between
sediment supply and accommodation space.
Mapping the southernmost Weichselian ice margin on the Dutch shelf using
multibeam bathymetry, sidescan backscatter and 3D seismics
Marcel Bakker, Sytze van Heteren, Freek Busschers
TNO – Geological Survey of the Netherlands
In recent years, the offshore extent of the MIS2 British-Irish Ice Sheet has been mapped in increasing
detail. High-quality bathymetric data and targeted surveys of closely spaced seismic lines in British
waters have helped understand its dynamics and complex behavior. The current consensus is that this
margin advanced and receded multiple times after 32 ka. At the time of their maximum extent, the
British-Irish and Fennoscandian Ice Sheets were connected. During a final readvance at 18 ka, they
were probably uncoupled, with the North Sea Lobe leaving till and tunnel valleys offshore Lincolnshire
and Norfolk. Thus far, bathymetric and seismic data with sufficient quality to identify traces of the
Weichselian ice were unavailable for Dutch waters. The resulting gaps in mapped ice extent in this
crucial area between Britain and Scandinavia hamper reconstructions of ice-marginal positions
through time. New Dutch multibeam data for the Cleaver Bank area show its glacially sculpted
bathymetry in unprecedented detail. Seabed slope in particular highlights parallel glacial grooves,
terminal and recessional moraines, and tunnel valleys. This set of landforms correlates well with
British geomorphological data. Backscatter analyses of sidescan-sonar data from the same area show
that the terminal moraine coincides with the southern margin of gravel at the present-day seabed.
The spatially matching hummocky landscape visible on shallow time slices from 3D seismics provides
additional information on the preserved glacial sedimentary environments and facies. Although
detailed analyses of the observed patterns still have to be conducted, it is clear that multiple moraine
ridges extend well into the Dutch part of the North Sea. If we can trace these ridges and related
features farther northeast with future multibeam surveys, it may become possible to understand how
the Weichselian ice sheets disintegrated, as an analog for the expected collapse of modern-day
Antarctic ice on the other side of the globe.
Coastal plain mapping for archaeological research: a new geological map of
the cities of The Hague and Rijswijk (the Netherlands)
Kay Koster1, Peter Vos1, Christiaan Rieffe2, Jeroen de Jong2, Hans Siemons2, Okke Dorenbos2, Hans
Koot2, Oscar Holthausen2, Chris Sueur2, Everhard Bulten2
TNO – Geological Survey of the Netherlands; 2Municipality of The Hague
1
We present a new geological map of the cities of The Hague, Rijswijk, and adjacent coastal plain (the
Netherlands). The geological map is the result of a collaboration between the Geological Survey of the
Netherlands (TNO-GSN) and the archaeological departments of the municipalities of The Haque and
Rijswijk. The map concerns an update of a map produced in 2007. This update was required, because
additional borehole data and archaeological information became available that allowed for more
detail and provided new insights in the natural and human development of the area. The objective of
the presented map is to support archaeological research by means of archaeological prospection,
paleogeographic reconstructions, and provision of off-site landscape context of archaeological sites.
The map is based on semi-automated queries on some 17,000 boreholes that are stored in a national
subsurface database managed by TNO-GSN. Furthermore, a high-resolution DEM was used to map
geomorphological features. Archaeological information regarding sites and age of finds are plotted as
an overlay on the map.
The map reveals the interplay between human occupation and late Holocene natural inundation
forced by relative sea-level rise, changing tidal amplitudes, upstream river avulsions, and embankment
breaching. This is reflected in the presence of severely decayed peat layers as a result of artificial
drainage, alternating with clay layers deposited during floods surrounding an estuary, tidal inlets, and
creeks. Furthermore, the new map shows a higher frequency of beach ridge – swale alternation in the
coastal barrier underlying The Hague than previously assumed. The map also shows that early human
occupation was primarily concentrated on higher areas.
Construction of a transnational offshore sand-resource model for the
southern North Sea area
Jelte Stam1, Jan Stafleu1, Sytze van Heteren1, Vasilis Chademenos2, Tine Missiaen3, Lars Kint4, Vera
Van Lancker2,4
TNO – Geological Survey of the Netherlands; 2Ghent University; 3Flanders Marine Institute; 4RBINS –
OD Nature
1
The TILES consortium has developed a 3D sand-resource model of the Quaternary deposits of the
Belgian and Netherlands part of the North Sea to support marine spatial planning and exploitation
(TILES-Transnational and Integrated Long-term Marine Exploitation Strategies; Van Lancker et al.,
2019: http://www.belspo.be/belspo/brain-be/projects/FinalReports/TILES_FinRep_AD.pdf).
Creating a transnational model requires a large effort in data compilation, integration and
harmonization. For best insights and quality control, models were constructed per area using similar
workflows and definition of common denominators. A stratigraphic layer model was first developed
using 2D seismic data differentiating between Paleogene, Pleistocene, lower and upper Holocene
units. This layer model served as a framework for the creation of a voxel model, a stack of voxels layers
on regular grid in 3d-space. The voxel model consists of a few million 200m x 200m x 1m voxels with
lithological attributes derived from a coding of descriptions of borehole and grab sampling data. For
the transnational model, the Belgian and Dutch databases were combined and further harmonized
using automated routines (Phyton) ensuring a repeatable workflow.
Voxel attributes comprise the main lithology (e.g. gravel, sand, clay), Wentworth classes (e.g. fine,
medium, coarse sand), and (adjusted) Folk (e.g. sandy mud, gravelly sand, muddy gravel). Admixtures
were also added (e.g. shell content, percentage fines (clay/silt, or < 63 µm) and/or gravel; organic and
glauconite content). Uncertainties were quantified as well, and relate to model and data uncertainty.
The latter was based on sampling type, positioning accuracy and year of drilling.
The resulting voxel model shows important trends in sediment composition and distribution, some of
them, hitherto not distinguished. The uncertainty parameters indicate areas where further data
gathering would be required to get a better understanding of the geology and sediment composition.
Figure 1. Probability that a voxel contains medium sand (from TILES final report 2019).
How tides and rivers shape levees and crevasses: Holocene overbank phases
of the Old Rhine river, the Netherlands
Harm Jan Pierik1, Jelle Moree1, Lonneke Roelofs1, Marcio Boechat Albernaz1, Antoine Wilbers2, Bert
van der Valk3, Marieke van Dinter4, Jasper Leuven1, Tjalling de Haas1, Maarten Kleinhans1
1
Utrecht University; 2IDDS Groep bv; 3Deltares; 4ADC ArcheoProjecten
Despite their importance for safety around estuaries, the formative controls on natural levees and
crevasse splays around estuaries are not well known. Here we focus on the levees and crevasses of
the Old Rhine estuary (active ca. 6500-1000 yr BP). Compilation of large amounts of geological data
and new field data allowed us to reconstruct levee and crevasse evolution over time, which we then
correlated to changing fluvial discharge, tides, and sediment supply. Numerical modelling in Delft3D
were used to test the inferred mechanisms.
Orientation, abundancy and size of crevasse splays indicates increasing tidal influence towards the
estuary mouth. Field data furthermore reveals two distinct phases of overbank deposition. Large scale
crevassing started as soon as floodplain vegetation changed from reed swamp to alder swamp from
5000 cal yr BP onwards. This occurred at that time that the tidal influence was large, because the
coastline was relatively close and the mouth was wide. Our model results confirm this by showing that
the tidal backwater effect penetrated far into the tidal river and that high frequency water level
fluctuations trigger crevasse formation. In the middle of the channel belts’ lifespan around 3800-3000
cal yr BP, - the thickest and siltiest levees formed and several crevasses closed, while new ones
opened. This coincides with infilling phases of the mouth, reducing the tidal backwater effect that feed
the crevasses, and as well as with increased river discharge from the Old Rhine. Our modelling
demonstrates that, besides these external forcings, floodplain setting (especially vegetation density)
and river discharge are important drivers in levee dimensions and phasing. These insights provide
important clues on what could be the effect of human induced changes in land use, sediment load or
river discharge on how sediment distribution in vulnerable wetland landscapes.
Classification and mapping of small-scale ‚complex’ Pleistocene
seismoacoustic facies in the Eastern North-Sea
Hanno Keil
University of Bremen
The glacial/interglacial history of the Pleistocene exposed the North Sea area to a variety of
sedimentation environments and processes. These ranged from a highly erosive shallow marine
environment including estuarine tidal processes to coastal development (e.g. dunes, marches), from
lowlands (e.g. meandering rivers, sand banks, lakes and swamps) to glacio-generic processes (e.g.
moraines, sanders, meltwater channels). Several ice advances further complicated the situation by
partially reworking and deforming the underlying sediments. High-resolution multichannel seismic
and sub-bottom profiler data consequently reveal laterally heterogeneous structures that, despite
some well-studied large-scale features like buried tunnel valleys, often lack dominant reflector
packages and shapes. They rather appear as complex small-scale Pleistocene reflection patterns and
are usually generally described like that as well (Fig. 1). A systematic classification of these shallow
subsurface patterns and a mapping of their distribution on a broader regional scale shall therefore
help to better decode and describe the regional exposure of the North Sea to different sedimentation
environments during glacial and interglacial periods. Questions regarding the detailed extensions of
individual ice advances, the transition between meltwater controlled and terrestrial controlled
drainage deposits, the extent of proglacial lake regimes as well as the interglacial marine realm can be
better addressed if their imprints on the depositional structures are better understood.
Multichannel seismic profile in the Southern North Sea. Several different small scale depositional
units can be recognized.
How tidal ingressions along the North Sea grow and heal: impact of storms
Harm Jan Pierik
Utrecht University
The Southern North Sea coastal plain has dramatically changed over the past thousands of years. The
position of the coastline shifted while the vast lowlands of the coastal plain experienced drowning,
displacement of rivers, or recovery by sediment import. Collapse of peatlands under human impact
and long term sediment balances played an important role in the coastal evolution. Besides these
gradual developments, however, major events such as storms, occurred. Currently, the relative
importance of storms on long-term coastal evolution is unknown.
I aim to make detailed reconstructions of storminess of the late Holocene using existing and new
geological and historical records. This will be combined with data (e.g. maps, boreholes) from
archaeology, geology, and geomorphology a new overview rises on landscape evolution.
Understanding the relative important of such events will help to better understand past coastal
evolution and possible impact of future threats of sea-level rise and changes in storminess.
Quaternary paleodrainage in NW Europe: a marine perspective
Samuel Toucanne
Ifremer
Reconstruction of paleolandscapes and drainage systems is a central topic in Quaternary sciences,
especially in NW Europe that is characterized by huge continental shelves that were dry and drained
by large rivers during glacial sea-level lowstands. This type of reconstruction evolved from the 2000’s
from a descriptive, ‘static’ approach to a more ‘dynamic’ one, due to the development of dating
methods that allowed, in an important way, the synchronization of the fluvial and glacigenic
sequences from the continental interior of Europe (e.g. North Sea, Baltic lowlands) to the marine
archives from the North Atlantic. My talk will aim to show how marine archives, together with the
terrestrial records, participated to this change and to the exciting results published these last years.
This includes the dating of the opening of the Dover Strait ca. 450 kyr, the subsequent routing of
sediment and meltwater from the European ice-sheet to the Bay of Biscay (via the Channel River) as
well as some discussions about mass balance changes of the European ice-sheet during the Middle
and Late Quaternary. Finally, I will discuss how meltwater floods, and the glacial NW European
drainage system as a whole, impacted on the thermohaline circulation and, by extension, on global
climate change. Specifically, I will present new results from the Channel River and the European icesheet that call for a paradigm shift in our understanding of millennial-scale climate change.
Exploiting sedaDNA to trace the impact of the Storegga slide tsunami on the
Doggerland paleolandscape
Roselyn Ware, Becky Cribdon, Rosie Everett, Martin Bates2, Richard Bates3, Simon Fitch4, Benjamin
Gearey5, Tom Hill6, Timothy Kinnaird3, Vincent Gaffney4, Robin Allaby1
1
University of Warwick; 2University of Wales Trinity Saint David; 3University of St. Andrews;
University of Bradford; 5University College Cork; 6Natural History Museum at South Kensington
4
Metagenomic sequencing of ancient sediment DNA (sedaDNA) is a valuable tool for reconstructing
the dynamics of palaeoenvironmental change.
Doggerland was a fertile land-mass in what is now the southern North Sea. This submerged landscape
retains valuable evidence about local Mesolithic communities, prior to its submersion and subsequent
excision of Britain from Europe. This submersion is considered a consequence of sea level rises in the
mid-Holocene, with the catastrophic tsunami triggered by the Storegga landslides speculated to have
played a pivotal role. Whilst there is extensive evidence for this tsunami observed across the northern
areas of the North Sea, there is little of evidence from the south, despite this area having been
predicted to within the expected range of the impact of the tsunami.
Sediment cores were taken from across Doggerland, guided by extensive seismic mapping. Evidence
based on established methods of traditional paleoenvironmental analysis, geochemical analysis,
coupled with sedaDNA analysis, has enabled the first identification of tsunami deposits. This is
supported by dating (radiocarbon and OSL) which places these deposits as contemporary to the
Storegga slide. Sequencing of sedaDNA identified microbial signatures of sulphur metabolism within
the tsunami deposits. We also identified sweeping shifts in plant communities, with an influx of
incongruous plant taxa within the deposit, consistent with the catastrophic effects of a tsunami.
We will discuss how these data enable us to identify potential tsunami deposits, assess the
environmental impacts, and establish how the morphology of the landscape impacted the tsunami’s
progression.
Resurfacing Doggerland genomes. Whole genome analysis of hunter-gatherer
remains from Doggerland
Eveline Altena1, Cosimo Posth2, Kathrin Naegele2, Johannes Krause2, Peter de Knijff1
1
Leiden University Medical Center; 2Max Planck Institute for the Science of Human History
Between the end of the last glacial maximum (~13000 BC) and approximately 6000 BC the area that is
now the North Sea was widely inhabited by Late Paleolithic and Middle Mesolithic hunter-gatherers.
The North Sea sealed and preserved the archaeological archive they left behind and because of the
excellent preservation of organic materials, their skeletal remains are regularly found on the Dutch
beaches or by fishermen. On land, however, early prehistoric human remains are rare and mostly
poorly preserved.
The excellent preservation of the human bone makes it potentially suitable for DNA analysis. Despite
the fast-growing number of ancient genomes, data from northwest European hunter-gatherers are
still rare. Therefore, human remains from the North Sea can play a crucial role in studying early
prehistoric northwestern European populations. Even though they lack a precise context, their
approximate origin is usually known, and they can be radiocarbon dated.
Tests we performed to investigate the preservation of DNA in divers bone fragments indicate that the
material is generally well suitable for DNA analysis. Based on these results we set up a project based
on a unique collaboration with private collectors who provided us so far with a collection of nearly
100 human bones. This continuously growing collection will significantly increase the presently
published dataset of hunter-gatherer’s genomes and allow for a more detailed insight in early
prehistoric society in northwestern Europe than ever before. Specifically, we aim to estimate the sex
to enable a detailed study on sexual dimorphism, get an insight in temporal and spatial genetic
variation in the North Sea area and how these people relate to contemporary populations in other
areas and learn about the biological selection these people underwent. Here we present our first
results.
The greenhouse gas emission potential of North Sea peat sediments
Tanya Lippmann1,2, Michiel in ’t Zandt3,4, Ove Meisel1,3, Nathalie Van der Putten1, Han Dolman1,3,
Freek Busschers5, Marc Hijma2, Mike Jetten1,3,5, Cornelia Welte3,5, Caroline Slomp3, Pieter van der
Velden4
VU University Amsterdam; 2Deltares; 3Utrecht University; 4Radboud University; 5TNO – Geological
Survey of the Netherlands;
1
Globally, marine sediments store 150 Gt carbon. Most of this carbon is deposited in shallow
sediments. These marine sediments are widespread, but little is known about their role in the global
carbon cycle. The methane emissions of carbon rich sediments into the atmosphere are largely
controlled by methane oxidizing bacteria and archaea. We investigated the geochemistry, methane
concentrations and microbial community composition of Early Holocene drowned peat in shallow
North Sea sediments.
We analysed and compared two sediment cores that were extracted using a vibrocorer. DNA was
extracted using an optimized PowerSoil extraction protocol. Microbial species abundance and
diversity were assessed by targeting the small subunit ribosomal RNA (16S rRNA gene). Nutrient and
methane concentrations of the porewater were measured alongside sediment physicochemical
parameters.
Geochemical data confirmed the marine nature of the sediments with occurences of nitrate,
ammonium and phosphate in the millimolar range. High levels of methane were found in the core
with lower relative abundances of methanogenic archaea. Both cores were dominated by archaea.
The potentially heterotrophic species, Bathyarchaeota, whose contribution to methane generation is
not understood, accounted for over 50% [of the] relative abundance in all archaeal communities.
Methanogenic archaea were most abundant in the younger peat sediments. Bacterial communities
were highly diverse in both cores and [were] dominated by aerobic and anaerobic organic matter
degrading guilds, indicative of marine carbon-rich sediments.
The abundance of methanogenic bacteria in one core but not the other indicates a complex
relationship between methane concentrations and its production and oxidation in North Sea
sediments. It is unclear whether this is related to peat degradation/humification, peat vegetation type,
or compaction as a result of Holocene climate change induced sea-level rise. Future culture-based
analysis and greenhouse gas flux measurements are needed to confirm the role of in situ microbial
communities in global carbon cycling.
Reconstructing environmental change in the North Sea using novel XRF-corescanning methods
Rick Hennekam1,2, Tatiana Goldberg3,4, Marc Hijma5, Freek Busschers3, Sytze van Heteren3, Jasper
Griffioen2,3, Gert-Jan Reichart1,2
Royal Netherlands Institute for Sea Research; 2Utrecht University; 3TNO – Geological Survey of the
Netherlands, 4Helmholtz Centre Potsdam; 5Deltares
1
Geochemical profiling of sediments is performed for multiple environmental purposes, such as (1) for
reconstructing past conditions (e.g., bottom water oxygenation, marine productivity, and sea level
change), (2) characterization of pollutants, and (3) forecast geochemical behavior to technology
implementation (e.g., thermal heat storage, and aquifer recharge). For these objectives, multielement analysis of discrete samples is used routinely as a procedure to geochemically characterize
sediments. Over the last 2 decades, X-Ray Fluorescence (XRF) core scanning has been established as a
fast and relatively inexpensive tool to obtain geochemical data from geological material. We
developed and implemented novel detector technology in the XRF core scanner, allowing the scanner
to provide quantitative data of trace elements – in addition to major and minor elements. The
suitability of quantitative XRF-core-scanning for geochemical characterization of sediments from the
North Sea is explored. Specific focus lies on the use of quantified XRF core scanning to deliver data on
sea-level rise (e.g., pinpointing marine inundation surfaces) during the Holocene.
North Sea sediments in a new light - possibilities and limitations of
luminescence dating
Jakob Wallinga, Tony Reimann, Alice Versendaal
Wageningen University & Research
Luminescence dating is a widely used Quaternary dating method that determines the last exposure to
light of quartz or feldspar mineral grains, i.e. the time of deposition and burial of sediments. In this
contribution, I will outline recent developments in luminescence dating and challenges for applying
luminescence dating in North Sea underwater settings.
Luminescence dating requires samples that are undisturbed and not exposed to light during sampling.
This is possible by obtaining sediment cores, that are opened and sampled in a darkroom equipped
with safelights.
Two quantities need to be determined to obtain an age:
1) The environmental dose rate, which is calculated from radionuclide concentrations of the
sediments. The dose rate experienced by mineral grains also depends on the burial depth and
especially time-average water content of the sediment. The latter may be difficult to reconstruct for
fine-grained sediments for which water contents may vary over time due to swelling and/or
compaction.
2) The total dose absorbed by mineral grains since burial, referred to as palaeodose. For Holocene
deposits, and those from the last glacial-interglacial cycle, quartz optically stimulated luminescence
(OSL) dating is usually the method of choice. The quartz OSL signal is rapidly reset upon light exposure,
and stable over the time-scales of interest. For older deposits, the post-IR IRSL (pIRIR) signal of feldspar
grains is more appropriate as it saturates at higher doses. The pIRIR method largely overcomes
problems of signal instability associated with previous feldspar IRSL methods, but at the expense of
using a signal that is less-readily reset upon light exposure. Other methods for palaeodose estimation
of relatively old sediments are under development (e.g. quartz TT-OSL and VSL).
Possibilities and limitations of luminescence dating North Sea sediments will be illustrated by some
recent applications, including new developments to use luminescence methods as sediment tracing
tool.
GEN-EX – Application of metagenomic analyses to extreme wave deposits in
the Shetland Islands, UK
Vanessa Heyvaert1,2, Tasnim Patel1, Max Engel2, Philipp Kempf1, Sue Dawson4, Isa Schön5
RBINS – Geological Survey of Belgium; 2Ghent University; 3University of Cologne; 4University of
Dundee; 5RBINS – OD Nature
1
The GEN-EX project addresses the issue of identifying extreme wave deposits through the application
of metagenomic techniques. Metagenomics, also known as environmental genomics or
environmental DNA (eDNA), is a technique where DNA is extracted directly from environmental
samples. GEN-EX has sampled tsunami deposits from coastal peat sections at three sites on the
Shetland Islands, UK (Dury Voe, Garth Loch and Maggie Kettle's Loch), dated to approximately 1.5, 5.5
and 8 ka BP (Storegga) and modern inter- to subtidal sediment sources. It is the first study in this area
to compare the results of foraminifera diversity using both classic and genomic approaches.
By applying classical micropalaeontological techniques, no foraminiferal tests have been found in any
of the Shetland tsunami deposits analysed to date. Inter- to subtidal offshore source deposits show
moderate to high foraminiferal concentrations, indicating that post-depositional dissolution of
foraminifera in the onshore tsunami deposits has most likely occurred.
Currently, Foraminifera are an underrepresented taxonomic group in genetic databases such as
GenBank and BOLD. Therefore, the project is firstly developing a molecular reference database of
recent North Sea foraminifera specimens. Using stringent precautions to avoid extraneous
contamination, foraminiferal DNA has been successfully extracted from individual modern
foraminifera and from palaeo- and modern sediments. Secondly, GEN-EX is now applying
metagenomics to the three tsunami deposits sampled in the Shetlands, UK. Amplification of this DNA
using primers for nuclear markers and Sanger DNA sequencing is in progress.
All molecular analyses have been complimented with an integrative and comparative approach
utilising geoscientific techniques such as grain-size distribution, CT scanning, multi-sensor core logging
and geochemical analyses. It is envisaged that the final eDNA results will be integrated with and extend
the classic ‘extreme wave event’ tool kit, which currently includes techniques ranging from
sedimentology, macro- and micropalaeontology, to geomorphology and geochemistry.
New developments in seismic techniques for archaeological prospection at
sea
Tine Missiaen1,, Wim Versteeg1, Maikel De Clercq2,3, David García Moreno2,4, Simon Fitch5, Vincent
Gaffney5
Flanders Marine Institute; 2Ghent University; 3Jan De Nul; 4RBINS – Geological Survey of Belgium;
5
University of Bradford
1
One of the main challenges in continental shelf prehistoric research is the wide variety in encountered
scale and environment. Both will strongly affect the applied seismic methodology or technique. Over
the last years much progress has been made in ultra-high resolution (UHR) subbottom imaging in very
shallow water (< 10m water depth). Using a novel multi-transducer parametric echosounder, unique
3D images were obtained from buried peat excavation patterns as well as remnants of old medieval
harbor structures in the intertidal zone off Ostend (Belgium), both with unprecedented detail (dm
level).
Archaeological prospection in deeper water still remains a challenge, and direct evidence of human
presence within the submerged prehistoric landscapes is seldom obtained. In 2018-2019 an important
breakthrough was made during two surveys in the southern North Sea. Combining HR sparker and
UHR parametric echosounder (PES) resulted in a continuous subbottom record ranging from the
seafloor down to 50-100m. The sparker data allowed identification of deeper structures such as river
valleys and lake depressions, whereas the PES data allowed the identification of prehistoric land
surfaces in the shallow sub-bottom in very high detail.
Subsequent targeted dredging resulted in the recovery of numerous samples of peat, wood, tree roots
and other plant remains from the seabed. The evidence strongly suggests the presence of prehistoric
woodlands. In one location, two pieces of worked flint were recovered. The latter not only
demonstrates that these landscapes were inhabited but also that we can, for the first time, prospect
for evidence of human occupation in the deeper waters of the North Sea with some certainty of
success. It also clearly illustrates that guided prospecting is the way forward, and we expect that this
approach will allow an important increase in archaeological finds in the near future.
Buried channels revealed by magnetic data
Seger van den Brenk1,, Robert van Lil1, Martin Koelman2, Michiel Küntzel2, Jan Graven3, Johan
Opdebeeck4
1
Periplus Archeomare; 2League Geophysics; 3DEEP Hydrography and Geophysics; 4Cultural Heritage
Agency of the Netherlands
In the recent years, the number and extend of the offshore areas which were surveyed with
geophysical equipment experienced a strong growth due to the development of offshore wind farm
zones. Magnetometers are used by default in geophysical research to map buried ferromagnetic
objects such as pipe lines and cables. However, the main application of the magnetometer is used
search for unexploded ordnance (UXO’s). Possible UXO’s can be located after processing and filtering
the raw data. The normal procedure is to remove all background noise until only the larger individual
magnetic anomalies remain. In this paper we reverse this process and focus on the background noise
of raw magnetometer data. The datasets of various surveys were re-examined by enhancing and
amplifying the background noise using different frequency filters. In some cases, the results show clear
channel-like patterns caused by the effect of the different magnetic characteristics by various
sediment types. The information of borehole data and seismic profiles at the locations confirms the
presence of sub-bottom channels, sometimes covered by meters of sediment. Different examples will
be presented, both of the inshore areas (such as the fresh water lakes in the Netherlands) as offshore
areas in the North Sea. With this new approach, both future and existing magnetometer datasets can
be (re)examined and provide new information on geomorphological phenomena like prehistoric
channels.
Magnetic lineations in the Markermeer area.
The Marine Prehistoric Sampler, new ways of survey on water
Axel Muller, Wouter Roessingh
ADC ArcheoProjecten
Collecting data about prehistoric occupation from submerged landscapes is common practice in Dutch
archaeology. Especially in the west of the country, there are many examples of surveys in drowned
landscapes, in areas that are reclaimed (polders). Fieldwork in areas that are still open water is very
rare. But recent sand and gravel extraction gave an opportunity to search for solutions or to improve
existing methods and practices. In recent years there have been archaeological surveys of submerged
landscapes in one of the large lakes of central Netherlands (Markermeer). In collaboration with
important stakeholders a new sampling technic was developed for sampling areas of a submerged
landscape. Due to this project progression was made in the practical challenge of collecting artefacts
form a difficult to reach place, but also in the process of assessment and evaluation of survey data to
get a better view of occupation and land use in submerged landscapes.
Determination of sediment transport mode based on grain size and shape
data from dynamic image analysis (1): testing a new methodology
Hans van Hateren1, Unze van Buuren1, Bas Arens2, Ronald van Balen1, Maarten Prins1
1
VU University Amsterdam; 2Bureau for Beach and Dune Research
The way in which sediment is transported (creep, saltation, suspension), is traditionally interpreted
from grain size distribution characteristics. However, the grain size range associated with transitions
from one transport mode to the other is highly variable because it depends on the amount of transport
energy available. In this study we present a novel methodology for determination of the sediment
transport mode based on grain size and shape data from dynamic image analysis. The data are
integrated into grain size-shape distributions and primary components are determined using endmember modelling. In real-world datasets, primary components can be interpreted in terms of
different transport mechanisms and/or sediment sources. Accuracy of the method is assessed using
artificial datasets with known primary components that are mixed in known proportions. The results
show that the proposed technique accurately identifies primary components with the exception of
background components (components that do not form a dominant contribution to any sample in the
dataset). Applications of this novel technique using size-shape data from two real-word sedimentary
systems - a present-day dune system (Van Buuren et al) and a secondary tidal inlet system (Prins et al)
along the Dutch North Sea coast - will be presented elsewhere during the conference.
Determination of sediment transport mode based on grain size and shape
data from dynamic image analysis (2): application to an active coastal dune
system
Unze van Buuren1, Hans van Hateren1, Bas Arens2, Ronald van Balen1, Maarten Prins1
1
VU University Amsterdam; 2Bureau for Beach and Dune Research
In this study we present a first application of a novel methodology for determination of sediment
transport modes based on end-member modelling of grain size and shape data from dynamic image
analysis (Hateren et al). Sediment samples from an active sandy coastal dune system along the Dutch
North Sea coast (National Park Zuid-Kennemerland) are used to assess the physical meaning of the
method’s output. Using end-member modelling, the grain size-shape distribution dataset is unmixed
into three primary components. The spatial distribution of these components is restrained by
geomorphology and reflects the three dominant aeolian transport processes known to occur along a
beach-dune transect: bedload (creep/saltation) on the beach and in notches that were dug by man
through the shore-parallel foredune ridge, modified saltation on the windward and leeward slope of
the intact foredune and suspension in the vegetated hinterland. The three transport modes are
characterised by distinctly different trends in grain shape with grain size: bedload shows a constant
grain regularity with increasing size, modified saltation a minor decrease and suspension a strong
decrease. These trends, or in other words, the shape of the grain size-shape distributions, can be used
to determine the transport mode(s) responsible for a sediment deposit. Results of the method are
therefore less ambiguous than those of traditional grain-size distribution end-member modelling,
especially when multiple transport modes occur in the sediment deposit and in the cases that primary
components overlap in terms of grain size but differ in grain shape.
Determination of sediment transport mode based on grain size and shape
data from dynamic image analysis (3): application to a secondary tidal inlet
system
Maarten Prins1, Youri Cuijpers1, Hans van Hateren1, Jan-Berend Stuut2, Simon Troelstra1
1
VU University Amsterdam; 2Royal Netherlands Institute for Sea Research
In this study we present a second application of a novel methodology for determination of sediment
transport modes based on end-member modelling of grain size and shape data from dynamic image
analysis (Hateren et al). Sediment samples from an active secondary tidal inlet system along the Dutch
coast – the Slufter nature reserve on the island of Texel – are used to assess the physical meaning of
the method’s output. The grain size-shape distribution dataset is decomposed into a series of primary
components by end-member modelling. The spatial distribution of these components is controlled by
the dominant transporting media (water, wind), geomorphology and vegetation cover and reflects the
main processes of sediment transport in this mixed aeolian-tidal sedimentary system: wave- and tidalcurrent-dominated bedload transport of ‘coarse’ sand on the beach and in the main inlet channel,
(modified) aeolian saltation of ‘fine’ sand in the coastal dunes, and suspension transport of ‘very fine’
sandy mud in the vegetated salt marsh.
The different transport modes and transporting media are characterised by different grain size-shape
distributions. Bedload transport by water is characterised by coarse sand and a constant grain
regularity with increasing size. Bedload transport by wind is also characterised by a constant grain
regularity with increasing size, but the distribution is finer-grained. Modified saltation transport by
wind is characterised by a minor decrease in grain regularity with increasing size. Suspension transport
by water shows a strong decrease in grain regularity with increasing size. The grain size-shape
distributions can thus be used to determine the transport mode (see also Van Buuren et al) and
potentially also the transporting medium for a sediment deposit.
Recycling vintage geophysical and geological data for cost optimization of
offshore wind farm design
Stefan Carpentier1, Jelte Stam2, Vincent Vandeweijer1, Bart Meijninger2, Koen Hermans1, Bob Paap1,
Anuska Kaliar2
TNO Applied Geosciences; 2TNO – Geological Survey of the Netherlands
1
With the growing development of offshore wind farms the demand for parametrized subsurface
models, (i.e. GeoTOP developed by TNO) as input for site selection and/or preliminary foundation
design rises. The geology of the upper 100 meters of the North Sea is highly variable but the amount
of (publicly available) geotechnical data from boreholes and cone penetration tests (CPT) is very low
compared to the onshore domain. To overcome this data shortage, we investigate how geophysical
techniques using vintage data can give new insights into the shallow subsurface. We plan to do this by
reprocessing vintage 2D and 3D seismic reflection data (originally acquired for exploration and
mapping purposes) to the point that it can be used to parametrize large parts of the subsurface aiding
in the optimization of wind farm design.
Using 3D seismic data the post stack reprocessing workflow starts by conditioning the seismic data
through broad-banding and denoising of the data with various techniques including Sparse Spike
Decon (SSD) and Non Local Means (NLM) algorithms. An example of how the SSD algorithm works is
shown in Figure 1. The NLM algorithm is also applied on a series of noisy 2D high-resolution seismic
data. Vintage logs and well data were gathered and digitized where needed (CPT, gamma ray, sonic,
density, checkshot) and tied to the 3D and 2D seismic data, completing the initial data set.
The next step is to create waveform inversions and attributes from the tied seismic data and
wells/CPTs to characterize and parametrize the shallow subsurface. This data will then be used in
offshore wind foundation design tools to evaluate the improvements in foundation costs of early
design iterations based on actual subsurface data.
Figure 1. 300 ms two-way-time vertical and 7,5 km horizontal in 2D Inline of 3D seismic cube in the
Dutch offshore. A) original post-stack section and B) broadband re-processed post-stack section. B)
has far more high-resolution features and details than are visible in A).
Figure 2. 100 ms two-way-time vertical and 5 km horizontal in 2D high-resolution seismic line in the
Dutch offshore. A) original post-stack section and B) NLM re-processed post-stack section. B) has far
more coherent features and continuity than A).
Figure 3. Overview figure of integrated dataset containing tied 3D seismic, 2D seismic, gamma ray
logs and CPT logs.
Reconstructing vintage seismic data for geological mapping of the Dutch
North Sea sector
Jelte Stam1, Maurits Beudeker2, Stefan Carpentier3
TNO Applied Geosciences; 2TNO – Geological Survey of the Netherlands
1
The Geological Survey of the Netherlands has a large archive with historical North Sea data. A vast
volume of vintage seismic data recorded in the 2nd half of the 20th century is recorded on paper
scrolls. These data are commonly of very high quality and can be the only available seismic information
for particular areas. They give valuable insights into the geological architecture and distribution of
sediment types in the North Sea subsurface. Over the past years, we scanned all paper sections to
make them available for further digital processing. A method to transform these scanned images to a
digital seismic format (SEG-Y) has been optimized and tested for several datasets. In the SEG-Y format
the historical data now fit the “create once, use many times” principle and can easily be included in
modern-day mapping and modelling programs. The aim for the near future is to make these datasets
easily accessible for the public through our open-access portal, helping users in science, government
and industry to increase their understanding of the North Sea.
Scan of a seismic section that was printed on paper scrolls.
The same seismic section as in figure 1, but now converted to a digital SEG-Y and displayed in 3D.
NewRV: A new multidisciplinary research vessel to replace the RV A962
Belgica
Lieven Naudts1, Pierre De Block2, David Cox3, Mark Arnalsteen1, RBINS-OD Nature MSO1, Defence Mr
Sys-n2, Patrick Roose1, Peter Degraer2, Luc Lams2, Yves Dupont2, Frank Monteny3
Royal Belgian Institute of Natural Sciences; 2TNO – Belgian Defence; 3Belgian Science Policy
1
The new RV Belgica will be a multipurpose, silent, green, ice-strengthened and full ocean research
vessel being able to work in water depths up to 5000 m and being able to deploy a large variety of
European marine infrastructure (incl. AUVs, ROVs, 3D seismic systems, sediment coring & rock drill
devices, etc.). The ship will have 13 labs with a total lab space of more than 400 m2. There will even
be deck space for seven gear and lab containers. The ship will be equipped with a full acoustic
underwater instrumentation suite which will allow the scientists to map and analyze the full water
column (incl. fauna), the seafloor and the subsurface.
New capabilities will be available such as dynamic positioning (DP-2), two integrated drop keels
allowing ad hoc instalment of subsea sensors and a roll stabilization system. All these systems will
allow the 28 scientists and marine technicians to perform their work as comfortable and as safe as
possible and this for the coming 30 years. The new ship will be at sea for 300 days per year and this
with a 30-day autonomy.
Based on these capabilities the new RV Belgica can support the complete Belgian marine science
community and will also strengthen the Belgian role in the Blue Economy via its researchers, training
centers and maritime industry. Ship time exchange with European research institutes will allow us to
enhance the research capacity and to enlarge the study areas based on shared costs. We also foresee
a financial return by deploying the new RV Belgica as an exploration- & test platform, a research- &
monitoring ship and an education- & training platform.
The delivery of the new Belgian research vessel is foreseen in autumn 2020.
Themes for discussion
How can we optimize public availability of data?
How can we streamline communal use of sample repositories?
How can we preserve (legacy) industry data and samples?
How can we set up a virtual research community?
How can we stimulate partner willingness to provide/share ship time and coring equipment
(EUROFLEETS)?
What are the key upsides and downsides of (combined) analytical methods?
What are the needs and requirements for training next-generation researchers?
How can we align national and European scientific funding (agencies)?
What is the usefulness of archeological data in geological mapping and research, and vice versa?
What is needed to link up well-known areas through newly surveyed corridors?
How can we generate transnational applied-geological maps?
How can we optimize the preservation of submerged heritage?
Panel:
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
dr. Josef Stuefer (Dutch Research Council)
dr. Koen Lefever (Belgian Federal Science Policy Office)
dr. Bob Hoogendoorn (Royal Geological and Mining Society of the Netherlands; European
Federation of Geologists)
dr. Margaret Stewart (British Geological Survey)
prof. dr. Volkhard Spiess (University of Bremen)
drs. Barbara Speleers (Cultural Heritage Agency of the Netherlands)
dr. Mieke Mathys (IMDC)